I have to admit, first time I saw the auger (on a machine at a friend's house 15 years ago, can't recall anything else about it except the cabinet was green), I thought, "darn!, that's clever!" because it would help pull blue jeans down at the center of the load. Blue jeans having a tendency otherwise to stay at the surface and move around more slowly than other items.
My mom has a new-ish Maytag with the auger agitator; when I go back to visit my folks during the holidays, I usually end up washing my stuff, and so far that machine seems to do just fine.
The criticism about these possibly being a bit rough on clothes (and the faster agitators) could be addressed by using the Gentle setting and, if needed, a longer wash time setting .