Comfort Food: The Unicorn Shepherds Pie recipe

Automatic Washer - The world's coolest Washing Machines, Dryers and Dishwashers

Help Support :

petek

Well-known member
Platinum Member
Joined
May 28, 2009
Messages
11,819
Location
Ontari ari ari O
Here's my favorite shepherds pie recipe I've used for years. Back in the 80's we ate at the Unicorn Pub in Calgary which at least at that time was owned by one or more of the Irish Rovers singing group.. You know that hit Unicorn song. Well it was delicious, just the kind of comfort food I like and it was a year or two later that their recipe showed up in the papers food section and I cut it out.

1.5 to 2 lbs hamburger
2 lbs potatoes for mashing
1 chopped onion
1 cup chopped carrot
1 cup chopped celery
2 garlic cloves minced
1/2 teasoon ground nutmeg (absolutely required)
Salt/Pepper to taste
8 oz (1 cup) beef broth
2 TBSP butter and a TBSP of cornstarch to make a roux (essential and butter is a better choice than margaring)
1 can of corn or peas (drained) or about a cup of fried mushrooms (my choice)

Start by peeling your spuds, cooking and mashing them (make them however you like,add what you like)

Fry the hamburger in a large skillet and drain
Add the chopped carrots, onion and celery and nutmeg, along with perhaps a teaspoon of salt and pepper
Let this mixture cook until the vegetables are wilted. (about 10 minutes)

In the meantime if you want to use mushrooms.. sautee them separately in butter.

Add the 8 oz of beef broth to the meat mixture and let it simmer for about 10 minutes.
Then take your butter/starch roux and mix it into the meat mixture to somewhat thicken it.

Pour the thickened meat mixture into a 9x13 oblong pan. It should be about 1" thick.

Top the meat mixture with either drained canned corn or frozen corn, drained canned peas.. or my preference the sauteed mushroom.

Spoon the mashed potatoes over the mixture and smooth it out.. run a fork over it to created grooves,,, brush some butter over the top

Bake at 350 for 35-40 minutes until lightly browned. Cool off on a wire rack for 10-15 minutes..

Have some beef or mushroom gravy ready to ladle over it on your plate.. YUM

Tastes even better the second and third day

Here's the meat mixture with the mushrooms atop along with the spuds before topping

petek++11-30-2012-20-19-56.jpg
 
Looks good!  looking forward to making it if we ever get winter weather.  Weird but I've been looking forward to a cold wintery night to hunker down and enjoy some hearty comfort food.
 
just made it --- Very good!

 

I took a liberty or two --used Quorn crumbles instead of hamburger as I avoid meat, and I was a little short on potatoes.  I will certainly make it again, it's quick, easy and very good.  A winner!

 

Have to say I've never made a roux with corn starch. interesting.
 
Having company next Thurs. & Fri evening and plan on making this one of the nights.  the other night will be King Ranch Chicken.
 
My company had a medical emergency and wasn't able to visit.  I had started working on the "base" when they called and said they wouldn't be able to make it.  So I completed the process.  Tonight I made a small batch of taters and made a small version that was baked in the oven.  It was wonderful!!  Peter don't have a stroke.  But I've not had good luck with potatoes freezing.  So I mixed the rest up with some whole wheat elbo mac and put it in single portions for my lunches.  I tasted a little bit and I liked it very much.  So I am looking forward to my lunches with a new recipe.  Will think of you when I have them. 
 
Sounds lovely....but

It really should be 'Cottage' pie...

While the terms 'Shepherds pie' and 'Cottage pie' are generally interchanged and in fact 'Shepherds pie' didn't exist until 1877 - possibly because someone thought 'ah, lamb - shepherds = more appropriate name'. Still, as a result, there is a tendency for one to be made with lamb and the other with beef and hence the name.
 
I tried this the other day, and we enjoyed it. My alterations were to cut the recipe in half, which fit nicely into an 8x8 baking dish, and I used a 24-oz. package of prepared mashed potatoes instead of making my own. Hubby said the recipe was a keeper, so thanks for sharing it!
 
This is my kind of recipe! Looks wonderful - I'm going to try this next time I have a couple of friends over that have hearty appetites!

I envy your Hostess find!! I never ate Hostess stuff that much, always thought it was too processed and artifical. Now that we can't get Twinkies anymore, I want them all of a sudden! Human nature - lack of supply increases demand!!
 

Latest posts

Back
Top