Lo-Fi is fun too!
Close'n'Plays were the ultimate lo-fi. It was basically a sapphire stylus connected to a plastic speaker cone. Yes, that was the amplifier. Luckily, yours is electronic and a little bit better. Still lo-fi but that's what most people had back in the 50s. Unless you were rich and had a console.
I'd be playing some Bubblegum pop on that player, like Ohio Express, 1910 Fruitgum, Partridge Family, Bobby Sherman, Tommy Roe, etc. Those little 7" Disney storybook records are fun to listen to on a small record player.
"You'll know it's time to turn the page when Tinkerbell plays her chimes like this..."