I think so Phil as far as TOL for 40" stoves of the time. I think by this time you could still get nice options in a stove this size. I do think it was the beginning of featured down, inflated prices for these larger stoves. Most people buying a 40 by this time needed a replacement to fit existing cabinet dimensions. Just opinion, no fact. I must admit this one does look nice not cheap like the current 40" offerings that are way overpriced.