I Gotta Say It:
For about a decade, I had a custom St. Charles kitchen. For about thirty years, my mom had a Youngstown kitchen.
There was absolutely no comparison in the quality. My St. Charles cabinets never gave the slightest trouble; Mom's Youngstown units were forever shedding their hinges, or spawning new patches of rust, or whatever. Even the metal gauge felt different, lighter on the Youngstown. My St. Charles units dated to 1981; Mom's Youngstown cabinets were from '62, so it wasn't a case of things being better just because they were older.
I always felt that a Youngstown kitchen was more for the meticulous housekeeper who was more interested in a showplace kitchen than in actual hard-knocks cooking.
EDIT: I should have mentioned - the factory paint was obviously thinner on the Youngstown, and edges didn't feel as well-finished as they were on the St. Charles. [this post was last edited: 1/6/2013-19:31]