Pods: A Prediction Comes True

Automatic Washer - The world's coolest Washing Machines, Dryers and Dishwashers

Help Support :

danemodsandy

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 6, 2006
Messages
8,180
Location
The Bramford, Apt. 7-E
Statistics are in from a year of detergent pod sales, and they are scary: over 17,000 American kids under the age of six suffered some sort of problem from ingesting pods or part of one. That's pretty much one child every hour between March 2012 and April 2013. The medical journal Pediatrics reports that 4.4% of these children were hospitalized, and 7.5% experienced a "moderate or major medical outcome."

When we were discussing this issue last August, I said this:

"....I also think that P & G has released a product into a marketplace that common sense should have told them not to put there.

Everyone and his brother and his little spotted dog knows that people are rushed, multitasking, self-centered, gabbling into cell phones and in general not paying nearly the attention to kids people used to give their offspring.

In such a social climate, the release of a product that damn near jumps up and down in front of kids singing, "Eat Me! Eat Me!" seems to have been a most unwise decision.

In a perfect world, detergent pods might have worked out just fine. The world we live in is not that world.

I have a good, hot hunch that liability concerns are going to bring the "pod revolution" to a screeching halt in the not-too-distant future."


Some efforts have been made to stem the tide of incidents. P & G has put a new lock on the containers, and the Consumer Product Safety Commission has asked - not mandated - that manufacturers create more childproof packaging.

But a kid an hour eating or getting eye damage from these things? That tells me that human nature is not up to the task of supervising children around pods, which says only one thing to me - the pods gotta go. A few incidents - or even a few hundred - you can put down to inept or inadequate parenting. A child every hour says to me: This. Ain't. Working.

I have a feeling that discussion on this issue is going to be lively.

Here's a link to a CNN report:

 
Sandy, you made a good point then and it's still a good point: the pod looks like something yummy to a child.  Do the modern laundry products even have a 'keep out of reach of children' like the older products did?  I was amazed when I just checked my latest box of Sunlight powder and it didn't have this warning. 
 
Dangerous Detergent Pods

I also saw this news and I totally agree these need to either be banded or drastically redesigned.

Although when we were having this discussion a year ago and NYC Writer said these were just part of the natural selection process and I suggested he put out a bowl of them to see how many of his friends will try eating them, I wonder if he did, LOL.
 
Paul:

Pods have a warning. Tide Pods have a safety lock on the container. But that child-an-hour statistic suggests to me that those measures are inadequate. People are lazy, distracted and often don't read instructions. It's very easy for a harried mom to leave a pods container unlocked because it's easier for her to reach for pods. Or to put a pod into the laundry basket she's about to take to the laundromat - and then Mom gets a distracting phone call while her baby is near the basket.

I just think pods are more than many people can handle, from a safety standpoint.
 
It doesn't help when said product smells like candy... I've never smelled Tide pods before but remember someone saying they smelled like candy. I did buy a pale of Tide Oxi recently and it smelled like Smarties, it made me want to eat it! Now imagine a little kid with the stuff...
 
There have been quite a few reports in the medical media here in Ireland about pods over the last decade or so.

The biggest issue seems not to be ingestion, it's actually eye and respiratory injuries.

Kids see them as being toy like. If you squeeze them, bite them or otherwise burst them they can spray super concentrated chemicals into your face, eyes, mouth and nose.

I'm not sure that the costs/risks are outweighed by the very slight convenience benefits.

I wouldn't have them in the house if there are kids around.

The new Persil pods actually look.like a teething ring! You know those chewy devices that babies chew on while teething.
 
On NBC news last night, they interviewed a woman who said that grandma gave one to the baby, thinking that it was a teething toy. Way to go, grandma!

Perhaps they can reformulate these so they only contain white detergent powder, sort of like how some dishwasher pacs are being sold. Those don't look nearly so entertaining, and they're hard, not squishy.

But they are still as convenient.
 
Just for comparison sake, are there any statistics anywhere that quantifies the numbers of poisonings from liquid or powdered detergents?? Surely that is in the thousands a year too.

There is NO doubt that people are generally careless and complacent about the dangers of many household products. Other then providing proper warnings this isn't the manufacturers problem.

On the other hand making the pods colorful and dare I say "bite size" is. I have some Gain Flings that smell delicious too, I was tempted to taste them!!! They do need to address this and make them all grey and unappealing visually. Perhaps a durable outer bag on each pod that has to be cut off. The Mr. Yuk campaign could be resurrected for this too.

The convenience of the pods is here to stay, but they best do something!
 
Well....

I have always had sympathy for Frigilux's idea that parents should take proper precautions and supervise their kids.

Unfortunately, that one-child-an-hour statistic more than suggests that our society does not give proper attention to those things. In light of that information, it's my belief that the continued manufacture and sale of pods in their present form is foolhardy.
 
To think, I handled this stuff & was into reading Warning Labels ("If Swallowed: _____") and proved trustworthy going into kitchen cabinets and under sinks to be potentially qualified to educate my peers...  Of which there were little, if no calls, in my time, that I ever knew of having to be made to Poison Control and/or to the E.R.

 

 

-- Dave
 
I've only ever seen one case of "injury by pod" come through my ER but then again I don't work there very often if I can help it. It was a babysitter, maybe 16-18 and she was telling me that she thought it was just soap and wasn't big deal until it burst and baby swallowed some which was quickly followed by vomiting and breathing issues. She hoesntly had no idea that laundry detergent is more than just soap and water, that there are chemicals within that are caustic when concentrated and encountered in their concentrated form. I never did get to finish explaining things to her as the mother showed up and that was a whole other scene.
I do think that companies need to work on their packaging but even so, these things will continue to happen unfortunately.
 
Modified packaging

Here in Australia, Unilever which produces Omo caps have modified the packaging which is now opaque so you can't see the caps in the box. Also the lid is more difficult to open.

Like all chemicals, they should be kept out of reach of children. It's just common sense, but unfortunately that now seems to be lacking more and more in society.

OTOH some people shouldn't breed. Maybe that would eradicate stupidity.
 
Storage

It does make me think, where are these pods being stored for kids to reach them?

The kids are not allowed in the Laundry room at all, on the odd occasion they have been in, we have been with them constantly.

There is a lock on the laundry room door that could be used if need be.

Also if stored in the kitchen, they should be in a cupoard with a lock, fitting a lock if needed.

As above there is always going to be an exception (such as putting a pod in the basket to take to laundromat etc) but 17000 separate parents not locking chemicals out of reach?

Oh.dear
 
1. Households with small children should opt for an alternative form of detergent.

2. Manufacturers should make pods less candy-like in appearance; containers should be childproof.

3. 43,000 children are injured or killed each year in bathtub/shower accidents (just for some perspective).

4. New Fad On Campus: College students are squeezing pods 'til they burst, then posting photos of the mess (usually on their hands, face, legs) on Twitter, Snapchat, and Facebook.

5. I'm off to play the trumpet and trombone for 3 hours.

[this post was last edited: 11/11/2014-19:17]
 
Sandy  I thought of you when I saw this article during my lunch hour reading.  Children going into comas was even mentioned.  Since parents can't be responsible enough, the product must be discontinued.  How many will end up with death before that happens?
 

Latest posts

Back
Top