With all due respect...
John, over my years in the field (and I have a few...), I have found the Maytag laundry has held up very well compared to many others. I have had all the above in my laundry room (or in my shop) and have had a chance or three to listen and examine. Now, granted that all brands have their strengths AND weaknesses, the Maytag laundry ran quieter, lasted longer and was built heavier than most.
BUT... It's almost impossible to compare brand vs. brand, let alone machines within the same brand due to design or quality changes over the years. Comparing MT Dependable Care washers from the 50's with the later models manufactured just before discontinuing the line, comparing the Dependable Cares as a whole against the other Maycor platforms such as Amana, Norge/Magic Chef, Neptune, etc. can lead to possibly heated debates. And let's not even get into the belt driven vs. direct drive Whirlpool topic. How about asking the Frigidaire boys about the likes/dislikes between Rollermatics, WCI designs up thru to the Electrolux era laundry. Speaking of Frigidaire being bought out by Electrolux, Maytag did not 'go out of business'. It still exists as a division of...
All that being said, I do enjoy the healthy debates that will always go on here due to the passioned people here. Everyone will always still have their favorite brand, design, year and model and will defend it tooth and nail. I think the namecalling, cheapshots at age or level of education/other criteria can be done without on ALL sides. Sometimes I think there is a bit of mutual 'button pushing' between Dan and John that is enjoyed.
Ahhh, but maybe that's the fun of it...
By the way, out of all the machines I've encountered in my 20+ years in the fied, my MAH Neptunes have ruled the roost longest in my laundry room...
RCD