I really like the 3 vane: they have a small foot-print and they roll-over like crazy. In the bigger tub, they will fit over the post and secure easily but there's a big gap between the agi bottom and the tub. I've messed around using it, but without a real load in the tub. There was a weird Whirlpool economy model automatic agitator whose fin plate stopped before the tub bottom, about 2 inches, but a collar then extended to the bottom. Corny looking thing--WHY?
The reason why I didn't doubt you is because of this: You're familiar with the 18 pound tub in the center dial Kenmore's with a dual action agitator. In John's Museum, he has one of those machines, but instead of the usual dual action agi, this one sports a mammoth 3 vane agitator, the same style and color of the 12 pound tub version but enormous. Had never seen it before or since. A real eye-popper and very exciting to watch in motion. His machine hums deep with the power of a small hydro-electic damn. I tried to steal it, but he caught me. LOL
Maybe, he'll take a pic for us all and post it.
I also have a few Kenmore Dials; let me see if they will fit on my Whirlpool. Is the stem or post to attach it to still viable, or is that gone, too? Couldn't tell from the pic.