I should've paid more attention to the beginning and how it looked at first. You're right, it was so far gone not much he could do to ruin it, and it's his tool to do with as he pleases.
Assuming he's not using it for heavy smithing work at least the face shouldn't separate. I wouldn't expect it to have any rebound whatsoever, even if he did use tool steel for the face plate. He would've been only able to weld the outside edges. The Gunther method uses two different types of welding rods, one to first buildup the table and then another to provide the right hardness.