I tried Dr. Squatch early on when they were bombarding FB with their commercials. I tried the Pine Tar and Bay Rum bars. First thing I noticed was how SMALL those damned things are! Not a good value for the price. Bay Rum was OK but the Pine Tar left me feeling pretty clean and I loved the smell. Problem was the damned bar lasted 2 weeks tops. And if I left it on the shelf where the shower stream hit it I noticed the water running down the side of the stall was black from the bar eroding and it lasted only a week! I switched to Shea Moisture African black soap with shea butter because my skin gets drier than the Sahara in winter and this is the only thing that prevents that soap wise. I still have to slather on moisturizing cream head to toe after a shower though. Out of all the soaps mentioned here which ones are best for severe dry skin?