in defense of Crawford
despite my better judgement, i will add a little to hopefully add some nuance to the crawford story. several things cant be disputed, she was a known alcoholic, she was an authoritative figure, and she was very emotionally needy/wounded. she grew up in poverty with her brother hal. her biological father deserted the family soon after joan was born. joans mother worked as a laundress (no joke) and life was not easy. no home, only rented rooms and work at an early age. joans mother anna heavily favoured her (more conventionally attractive) brother hal, and most of the chores were joans to do. one of joans few joys in her childhood was her adoptive father named cassin. he doted on little joan and she was allowed to participate in his vaudville/roadshow. this joy was not to last because cassin left the family and joan without a goodbye, before joan was a teenager. she never (i think) fully recovered from her father abandoning her. all she had was her mother. and mother was busy working and to add insult, her brother hal was moms standout favorite. in short, joan grew up having NOBODY to rely on. she really grew up feeling not loved. she had to rely on her OWN strength. this is one area where i strongly identify with joan. fast forward to her success, the reason joan loved her fans so much is because she was starved for love. but of course, the love of movie fans is no substitute for true love. i think when a child grows up feeling unloved or abandoned, they dont ever realy LEARN HOW to love. i suspect she believed adopting children would somehow complete her or make her happy. but as we know, children dont grow up knowing what gratitude is. and why should they, raising children is a labor of love. imagine a person so starved for approval and affection faced with an opinionated headstrong child. my mother was very similar to joan in this respect. the regular stubborn-ness that children often give was interpreted by joan as feeling unloved or unaccepted. add alcohol to the mix and the result is not pretty. a person who achieves the success of crawford often has to endure countless indignities on the way to the top. for someone with joans unfortunate past and current great success, rebellion from a child is a hard pill to swallow. joan was used to doing things HER WAY. and as folks with children know, you cant fight every battle. its not healthy. it is widely believed that joan knew about christinas plans to write "the book" before she died. i think christina actually did begin writing the book before joan died. joan disinherited her as a result. the opinionated and headstrong christina MUST have been affected deeply by this. although not too important, i should add that some of joans best friends throught her life were gay men. william haines, a popular mgm actor in the 1920s took her under his wing back when she was a nobody and was her best friend till his death in the 70s. she was also devoted to ceasar romero (gay) who she called "butch". joan first became a star in the late 1920s as a jazz-dancing "flapper" and continued to have her name above the title into the 1960s, albeit in less prestigious films. she was probably a bad mother. she was undoubtedly a troubled and wounded soul who through sheer will and discipline carried on and did what she had to do to be one of the most successfull actors in cinema history. please dont hold this rant against me folks. the end, David