Is a more expensive crockpot (slow cooker) worth it?

Automatic Washer - The world's coolest Washing Machines, Dryers and Dishwashers

Help Support :

If I had an electric stove, I'd probably look into an electric pressure cooker, since adjusting the burner settings on an electric stove just right can be tricky without a "smart" burner.  Since I have a gas stove, using a stove-top pressure cooker is a cinch. 

 

The only advantage an electric cooker would have is automatic shut-off, but generally I'm working in the vicinity of the cooker while it's cooking, and the ancient method of setting a mechanical timer works fine for me.
 
I have had no problems adjusting the burner settings, but then again, we have an induction stove, so the adjustment is actually faster than when we had a gas stove. The auto off is no big deal for me either, the timer works just as well, but like Ralph, I tend not to leave the kitchen when I have stuff on the stovetop, particularly pressure cookers.

But I have many friends that love Instant Pot and Power Pressure Cooker XL etc -- they all have kids, and while the electronic pots are slower than a regular pressure cooker on the stove top, they like it that they don't *have* to be in the kitchen because the machine will regulate the temp just fine and turn off when the timer goes off.

In any case, I was just taking a look at Cook's Illustrated website and they're not in love with the multi cookers -- pardon me the pun, but I'd take their opinion with a grain of salt after I've seen what they "recommend" to cook rice in a pressure cooker (I bought their book on pressure cooking and after looking at that recipe I'm not sure I trust the rest of the book, super complicated recipe). In my home, I just put the quantity of water and rice the pot manufacturer recommends, for the appropriate time -- sure, it means I need to remember different ratios of water and time for 3 different manufacturers, but they are pretty close, while Cooks Illustrated's method is a nightmare just to have "one" recipe that "works" in every pot.

Either way, people looking for multi-cookers, buyer beware and some research is needed, but I suppose it'd be a great option for some people if it works.

Good luck!
 
Yes, I must dare myself to make!

The pickled/pulled pork sounds good! I can imagine how neat it would be w/ banana peppers or jalapeños!

As for barbecue sauce, most recipes call for a mixture of dry mustard, apple cider vinegar, etc. so I bet there are lots of homemade sauces that you can make for it, or even store-bought ones must work just as good...

-- Dave
 
Something to remember,

About the electronic pressure cookers as opposed to the electric pressure cookers. The electronic units All run at 10lbs, the electric at the standard 15lbs. 

The difference is day and night in speed. If you live at 1000 feet, they can't even reach canning temperature at 10lbs, by the time you get to 3000 feet, you might as well not even bother with10lbs, it's useless.

Since you can put an electric running at a true 15lbs on a timer, there's zero arguments for an electronic except below 750 feet.
 
The Power Pressure Cooker XL has a canning cycle that reaches 11.6 psi, so it not correct to say that electronic pressure cookers only reach 10 psi. However, I would only can things in it like low acid veggies and meat at sea level, not at high altitudes. I have not used the canning feature, although I've been tempted to use it for food.

It also has a slow cook menu option, which I also haven't used.

My main complaint about the PPCXL (I have the 8qt version) is that the menu options are too restrictive. For example, you can't manually adjust their times beyond what the longest menu option allows. In other words, it's dumbed down too far. My solution has been to use a different menu option than the food it's supposedly tailored for. For example, for brown rice, I'll use the beans option to get the longer time I think they need. I think the pressure is exactly the same for these two menu options. The canning option allows for more flexibility in time adjustment... but it's probably dumbed down too.

The Cuisinart allows me to cook brown rice for 30 minutes, which seems to be close to ideal (for my taste, as it produces less crunchy brown rice). The max rice setting on the PPCXL is, I think, 25 min.

The other PPCXL complaint is that the little cook book that comes with it is inadequate, and the recipes on the PPC website are full of obvious errors, and some not so obvious. After this experience I find watching Eric Thiel on the TV infomercial to be more unpleasant than most (not that I watch for very long).

Instant Pot gets much higher ratings by CR, than the PPC. They dinged the PPC for being too slow with a warranty not much longer than the life of a fruit fly. The Cuisinart came in the middle, more or less.
 
Darryl bought one of those Ninja 3-in-1 or 4-in-1 or 3265235623563-in-1. Not sure exactly what model. Probably bought at QVC, HSN or whatever other late night infomercial.

Theoretically it's a slow cooker, tabletop oven, stovetop, that also works as a rice cooker, vegetable steamer, laundry soaker and when not in use it also sings, dances and performs as a drag queen.

Not so strangely (knowing my husband) it sat in his car's trunk for something around 2 years, now it sits in the garage, still in it's original shipping box, unopened.

This thread made me a little curious about slow cookers for the first time ever as I never had a slow cooker before, never used one, never needed one and until now I don't understand very well why use a slow cooker or how a slow cooker can be useful.)

Anyway, is that Ninja Slow cooker any good? What can you guys tell me about it? Depending on the answers, i may feel encouraged to open the box and give it a try, or forget that box is there taking space in the garage for other 2 or more years.

Please note that my question is about it's usability, not it's durability, as we will not buy one, it's already home. I just want to know if it's worth opening the box (my husband bought before we got married) or simply avoid wasting my time and ignore it exists.

 
Thomas:

For most people, a slow cooker is a godsend -- in theory, you load it in the morning or the night before with things that will be cooking for a loooong time (4-8 hours, although some recipes need 12) and all the flavors will meld into something divine, the meat will be falling off the bones, and you wake up or come home to a perfect meal you did not have to pay any attention to, stir, etc.

And, for many people that is true: I have a friend who makes a "disappearing chicken" for the holidays, and yes, it looks and tastes fabulous and as soon as she declares it done, a line forms and *poof* it's gone, there's no time for seconds or anything. Other friends make pulled pork etc.

I was never that lucky, when I try it, things taste "processed" like canned food and cleanup is annoying.

I should not complain, because usually, I don't have the patience anyway, *and* most things I cook in pressure cookers come out fabulous in less than one hour and folks usually complain about how hard it is to make pressure cooked stuff not taste like canned food, so I suppose we're even.

That all having been said, I'd say try the appliance, worst that happens is it doesn't work so well or you don't like it, then you put it back in the garage or give it to some charity to sell it in their stores.

I have never tried it for say feijoada, but I'm supposing given how everyone says that the best feijoada is made over several hours, it might work pretty well. I would try it, but, gosh, did you know there are at least 3 restaurants around me that make it and we need to help the neighbors with their business, right? ;-)

Have fun!
 
Crock Pots

To me were always useless appliances that wasted space, if you have an electric stove top you can use any covered pan or dutch oven on a stove top element on the low setting and get the same results and if you are like me and don't like to plan and start dinner 6-12 hours in advance you can use a pressure cooker and have a fresher looking better tasting meal in under and hour.

 

Its sort like a rice cooker which is absolutely useless if you have an electric range. It seems like all the houses I go into with gas cook-tops are the ones with these space wasting hard to clean appliances.

 

John L.
 
11.6 is just about 80kPa

Which, at sea level, and assuming it's dead accurate and the timing is perfect is just barely adequate for canning.
We had a lengthy discussion about this a while back. I consider it too low, there's no safety margin.
 
Nope

I disagree about the tastes of things cooked slow in a crock pot vs. a pressure cooker.  There's no contest as far as I'm concerned.  As Paulo stated, a lot of things made in a pressure cooker end up tasting like canned food.  Because of that, I'm particular about what I use a pressure cooker for.  On the other hand, I don't think I've ever had a bad meal from a crock pot.

 

And yes, I own a gas range because I prefer cooking on one, and I have three small appliances taking up space:  a coffee maker,  a toaster, and a mixer.   I'm betting owners of electric ranges have those same items within easy reach. 

 

And let me just say that there's nothing difficult about cleaning a rice cooker.
 
Some foods are better slow cooked. Others are best steamed for just a few minutes, or stir-fried. Still others beg to boiled, or baked, or grilled.

I see the point about not getting a plethora of single purpose cooking gadgets. I also see that one cooking gadget, no matter how clever, can do it all. Suffice to say I've accumulated more than my rightful share of cooking gadgets, but there are worse vices.
 
an easy pork or beef roast recipe

Stick a pork or beef roast in the crock pot.  Smear a can of cream of mushroom soup over it.  Chop a medium onion and dump it on top of all that.  A little black pepper to taste.  Cook all day or overnight and it will come out fork tender and taste soooo good.  Sometimes I add a little white wine at the beginning for flavor but it just depends on my mood.
 
Rice Cooker...

The only rice cooker i've ever had in my life was a tiny Black and Decker one... I think it was 3 cups... had a glass lid... it was excellent!

It would allow the brazilian rice (first pour some oil and chopped garlic) mix to spread the garlic.... put the lid, turn on... in about 2 minutes it would turn off. Then add the rice stir, turn on... when the rice is almost starting to burn it shuts off again... then pour the water and salt, turn on again..... perfect results!

When ready it will turn off, then you just turn on again (it will run for more 2 minutes maybe) only to start burning very lightly the bottom (my favorite). all done!
 
On this note I would also like to know if we can continue to use our slow coocker as the ceramic insert has hundreds of small cracks all through the pot. Another thing that bothers me is the taste its almost as if all the food that comes out of that thing tastes the same, could it be the cracks in the Ceramic pot?

Your advise is truly appreciated.

Regards
 
My stoneware only has utensil marks, I think the ceramic is very durable--even for the lot of use, at one point, on a slow-cookie'-streak!--I had given mine--and I even put it in the dishwasher...!

-- Dave
 
Mine is small,

an inexpensive Rival model. I made a 4 lb. sirloin pot roast yesterday with 2 lbs. of quartered red skin potatoes, one medium chopped onion, crimini mushrooms, baby carrots, and about a pound of fresh green beans on the top.
One packet of onion soup mix, chopped garlic, bay leaf, and 1/2 cup water.
There was no fat on that meat. In 4 hours on high, it was fall apart tender. The beans still had a bit of bite. A meal for four easy.
I halved the roast, and circled the crock with it. Carrots and potatoes in the center upward.
I've tried using an electric pressure cooker, and either it's me not knowing how they cook, but I didn't have a good result. Way under done. I followed the instructions. I allowed the pressure to build before I timed it like they said.
 
Ok, then I think I must get rid of my slow cooker. Maybe it has reached the end of its lifespan. Apparently if there is any cracks in the Ceramic lining it could leach lead, but don't quote me on that.

It will give me an excuse to go out and buy a new one.

Cheers
 

Latest posts

Back
Top