Washer Newbie -
What is the exact model number of your machine? You said it is a 1984 80 series, correct? Is it a suds-saver or a non-suds?
If you don't know the model number, do you remember which pump you bought?
I ask because I want to determine how water is flowing. Suds models will flow water in two directions through the tub grommet. This in my experience increases the likelihood that the grommet will leak during the wash/rinse agitate phase, which sends water from the pump, up through the grommet into the tub.
On the other hand, non-suds models do not recirculate water through the grommet, and it is used simply as a drain plug of sorts during agitation. Water does flow through it during drain however.
Your chances are probably marginally better of re-sealing a leaky grommet if you have a model that DOES NOT send water up through the grommet during agitation.
It would be a toss-up for me if this were my problem. Pulling the outer tub and replacing the 93553 grommet will almost always repair a leak there. Unless the baseplate is rusted to the point that the grommet cannot sit flat, a new 93553 is a big gift to the machine. These are NLA so grab one at Sears while you can.
Pulling the tub though may be difficult if the center grommet, which must be changed also, is stuck to the centerpost, especially if you goo'ed it in with POR-15. This will also at times cause weakened edges on the tub where it meets the center grommet to break off. This makes a re-seal with a new center grommet difficult. I used to say impossible, until doing some repairs with 2-part epoxy at weak points.
If you know your tub doesn't leak from the center grommet (they almost always do at some point, at least the later production models) I would try sealing the old 93553 first, but not expect 100% success. If that works, cool, stop there. If not, proceed to pull the tub, replace the 93553 grommet AND the center grommet, seal the centerpost down lower with POR-15 not that more of it is exposed, and re-assemble, knowing that the tub may need some work prior to completion of the project.
If you do decide to pull the whole tub, let us know as there are more removal tips I want to give you. But, no, you haven't killed your machine yet!
Gordon