Hi! Graham, according to the Pix's, these both look to me to be the same Parts, basically with just a different Part Number. You should be able to get either, but I'm suggesting the one I've included here. Good luck with getting them. You might still try at a local Sears Parts Department, to see if they still have them available, in order to save the Shipping
Cost. What is the Model of your Kenmore Washer, that your trying to locate these Lid Bumpers for?
I did replace some similar bumpers with ones I found at the Hardare Store, they were a little more cone shaped but stood up just as high. Alot less than $5 though.