Bakelite hands down.
"Is the base of the agitator bigger in my 108 than in my 806?
I know the agitator for the 806 is taller, but is the base wider in the small capacity tub?"
The answer to both of those questions is , no. The white and blue tubs are the same diameter as are the agitators. In fact they're interchangeable AFAIC. The newer agitators in the 1990's models with the extra fins have narrower bases and are overall IMHO, inferior agitators.
What I was told by one of the docents on this site, and I've seen myself, is that the water distributor cone underneath the old bakelite agitator really shoots a powerful stream of water from underneath the agitator that the later powerfins don't have. Instead, the water recirculates out of the lint filter column from four openings above the fins. It does make a difference.
And as far as I'm concerned, as much as I love and respect Wash Power Maytags, they couldn't hold a candle to the early Filter-Flo's(before the asinine straight vane activators)with respect to effective agitation. And Tom, I so agree with you about Consumer Reports; how they missed that is beyond me. I think their "scientific method" needed to be rated by an independent organization.
