Neptune or FriGEMore?

Automatic Washer - The world's coolest Washing Machines, Dryers and Dishwashers

Help Support :

volvoguy87

Well-known member
Platinum Member
Joined
Jul 19, 2006
Messages
2,571
Location
Cincinnati, OH
Of all the used front loaders on the market these days, these two types seem to get the most discussion here. I am not looking to obtain either one, but I am curious as to which one is the better of the two and where their strengths and weaknesses are.

This could be lively,
Dave
 
Longevity

Both Peter and I have Neptune frontloaders. His is one of the original run that received a free factory update on the wax motor and control board. Neither machine has had a repair since. It washes daily for a household of 4 adults. My set is just 4 years old and digital which came from a family of 5 before me. I prefer the dial and pushbuttons the older machines have because it makes it so much more flexible. The Maytags do an adequate job. I am still on a frontload learning curve. The Maytags are easier to remove the laundry because of the huge dorr and tilted tub. All things considered I would choose a Maytag if we're talking older models and a Sammaysungtag if new.

mixfinder++2-16-2010-23-42-22.jpg
 
Pros and Cons

Probably for the reason being, these designs first introduced a whole new wave of frontload washers, sure there were others out there like Asko, but at a highprice/small capacity didn't strike anyones real interest...and as new products come out you always have proto-types with glitches...but my opinion is these first few designs started a whole new wave in energy/water conservation, but the newest ones with the washing with drops of water have gone too far...probably the best choice is to pick a machine with a lower TIER for energy use...the idea is the lower the TIER, the more water that is used for better results, at least to our liking, per pound of laundry, and the worst part of the new machines out there is theres no way of making adjustments to water levels as before...so it kinda makes me hold on to the sets I have cause the new ones are getting worse....

I have 2 sets, the first one I got in 2000, and just did bearings last year, the second set I got off craigslist last year and also had to do bearings, other than that no real issues...

yogitunes++2-17-2010-04-22-49.jpg
 
This set is also part of my daily drivers (did I mention I have a family of 8, laundry non stop)...prefer the older version with the small door, where you could adjust the water level from inside, not so with this new one, so I Improvised with a little extra tubing and a 3 liter bottle, which allowed me to increase the water level anyway...

yogitunes++2-17-2010-04-29-21.jpg
 
I have a 2002 Frigidaire front-loader which has given me no problems at all. It has been oversudsed many times and I use liquid chlorine bleach on several loads a week.

Prior to this washer, I had an original-issue 1996 Frigiaire/Electrolux-based. Used that until I moved in '02. Never had a problem except for the timer, which I broke. It is still in service for a building with two apartments.

Although others around here have had bad experiences with Frigidaires, I can't complain.

Note: The top-loading Frigidaire is a 2006, which I use for a couple of loads a week, as it's fun to watch the indexing tub. The front-loader is my daily driver.

frigilux++2-17-2010-06-23-37.jpg
 
Maytag Neptunes

I have the second issue model Maytag Neptunes (with pushbuttons), purchased May 1999. Never had any issues with them. I am completely satisfied with these machines.
 
Identical Cousins

These are the Kenmore offerings of the Frigidaire models shown by Yogitunes. I have owned them since July of 2005 with no problems and no complaints. My laundry load is not heavy, however, maybe two or three loads per week.

nurdlinger++2-18-2010-06-15-29.jpg
 
The main problem I saw with the Neppies was a result of their stupid suspension, two struts from below in the middle of the outer tub and four springs suspending it. With this arrangement, an unbalanced load could start the tub fishtailing where the ends would pivot side-to-side. You could look into the back and see the whole suspended mechanism swinging back and forth. If Maytag had done it right, they would have used 4 struts underneath, 2 in front and two in back, but it was a cost cutting thing. Of course, I was prejudiced against any front loader without a window, but the trouble it could have with the balancing was the third strike for it in my book. I think someone here figured out that you could not choose Max Extract with jeans because it only gave two tries at balancing while the regular spin gave more tries. So after jeans went through the regular spin, the machine could be set for Max Extract if you wanted that for jeans.

When Maytag came out with the Neptune, you would have thought that they had invented the horizontal axis washing machine; forget about Bendix or Westinghouse. Forget that Maytag even offered a tumble action horizontal axis wringer washer sometime in the 20s, I believe.
 
To clarify,

I meant FriGEMore as the smaller round door style like the one pictured by Frigilux. Is this style still being made? They seem to be a more BOL machine, but have higher than expected reliability due to the mechanical controls. Their greatest weaknesses that I know of are the tub bearing (is this replaceable?) and the spider corroding.

These little FriGEMores seem to be pretty reliable, but how do they perform in a stock configuration (not much water)? The Neptunes, however, seem to be generally more rugged and may perform better, but seem to have more mold problems and there are some out there with the wax motor and control board issues.

Interesting,
Dave
 
My life with Maytag Neptunes

I bought the first generation Neptunes in 1998 (dial and push buttons). Went through 3 wax motor locks and motor control boards. They also replaced the boot on a recall for mold problems (which I did not have). I got a full refund (lemon law)for the washer and got to keep it. Maytag finally got the wax motor lock right and the washer is still running today at my brothers house. The dryer too,is still running and never had any problems.

My sister bought the Neptunes in 2003 (touch screens) and still has them today,no problems.

I bought Kenmore HET3 front loaders in 2004. Hated both the washer and dryer and took them back after 6 months and got Maytag Neptunes again (touch buttons). Still have them today,no problems at all.

spankomatic++2-22-2010-01-08-15.jpg
 
4
Neptune dryer I like the lint filter in the front and the cool down cycle,continuous tumbling for 10 min before it goes into that on and off tumbling thing.

spankomatic++2-22-2010-01-14-28.jpg
 

Latest posts

Back
Top