On The Quest For A New Powdered Laundry Detergent

Automatic Washer - The world's coolest Washing Machines, Dryers and Dishwashers

Help Support :

qsd-dan

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 24, 2007
Messages
7,235
Location
West
So I was just officially informed that Kirkland Institutional powdered detergent has been discontinued after being AWOL from the shelves the past few months in my area. This has been my go to detergent since the 90's. While I quit using it for cold washes around 2008 and recently for warm washes in the past year (Kirkland free and clear liquid for those cycles), I exclusively use it for pre wash and hot wash cycles. Since it's a nonbiological detergent, I can dump it in 160F hot wash/soak cycle with oxy bleach without feeling guilty about unnecessary enzyme death.

I noticed Costco carries Nellies Laundry Soda. Surprisingly, the reviews seem to be quite impressive for a natural product. Just wanted some opinions on that detergent for those who have experimented with it.

I know Tide is king in the realm of powders but the aroma is too overbearing and long term use causes rash breakouts. Gain has identical results. Foca was kind of "meh" in performance region and that was back when it still had phosphates although I was using it under hard water conditions and I have a softener now. Cheer seems like a waste for my purpose as it's catered towards preserving dark colors. Haven't tried ALL in nearly 30 years. Any opinions are welcomed.

It sounds weird, but losing this detergent is actually kind of an emotional experience that really caught me off guard, like I lost a family member. I'm not a detergent whore like others here so I just use what works well and stick with it as long the performance remains the same and I don't break out.
 
Non-bio in TOL detergents seems rare in USA.

If your wash isn't highly soiled All Free and Clear works well enough I find.

 
free and gentle powder?

Good option, I didn't even know that existed in powdered form.
 
Most powdered detergents sold at janitorial or commercial/laundry supply places are heavy on alkaline substances (washing soda, sodium metasilicate, etc...) and usually light on enzymes, activated oxygen bleaching systems and other things you find in TOL consumer detergents like Tide or Persil.

Yes, there are better options available for industrial or professional use, but they tend to cost more than standard run of mill bottom shelf product. There is a reason why 10, 20 50 or whatever huge amount in pounds of these products cost comparatively little.

https://www.ewg.org/guides/cleaners/5179-KirklandSignatureInstitutionalLaundryDetergent/

Anytime you see a laundry detergent that is also marketed to clean floors, walls, and other surfaces, that says something.

https://dazzly.mybigcommerce.com/kirkland-signature-institutional-laundry-detergent-200-wash-loads/

Commercial or institutional laundries aren't bothered by higher pH levels because that is how soils, grease, and even certain marks such as blood are shifted without using enzymes. Also within confines of short wash cycles of about eight to twelve minutes chemicals work better. This of course is coupled with fact commercial/institutional laundries consider "warm" water 120 degrees F, and "hot" between 140 and 170 degrees F.
 
Last time one checked many years ago Kirkland detergents were made by Huish. That company was bought by Sun Products (now Henkel North American Consumer Goods).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sun_Products

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henkel_North_American_Consumer_Goods#Henkel_Corporation_(2018-present)

Like everyone else nowadays Kirkland has various pods and liquid detergent offerings. Maybe it was like many other brands, Kirkland decided to stop powders and focus on liquid format laundry products.
 
losing this detergent is actually kind of an emotional exper

Lots of products that've been around decades or longer have disappeared.

Johnson Baby Powder with Talc for example: All you can get now is that smelly corn starch crap that has the consistency of chalk.

Latest casualty is my favorite Gillette Foamy sensitive skin shave cream. It disappeared off the shelves for a month or two then reappeared with an ugly redesigned logo, well the idiots at P&G decided to redesign the scent also!!

It always had a pleasant light soapy scent, now it smells like some awful cheap cologne that stays in your nostrils long after washing it off- Totally unusable.

WTF? Why would they mess around with a best selling product like that?

To me the scent was the main selling point in addition to being a good shave cream.
 
Talcum powder, long staple of the nursery and "powder rooms" had to go.

https://www.drugwatch.com/talcum-powder/does-talc-cause-cancer/

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talc#Safety

https://www.safecosmetics.org/get-the-facts/chemicals-of-concern/talc/

As with asbestos talc may end up costing J&J (and probably others) really big money from legal proceedings.

 
I honestly don’t really know what detergent I could recommend, but since I’ve used Maytags over the years, a low sudsing detergent that doesn’t kick up many suds would be my choice. Low sudsing detergent is also recommended for anyone who has a Whirlpool belt drive washer since they are known for suds locking very easily and I’ve done it a few times already.
 
Could you please provide a definition of "detergent whor

 

Latest posts

Back
Top