Reverse Creaming

Automatic Washer - The world's coolest Washing Machines, Dryers and Dishwashers

Help Support :

ea56

Well-known member
Platinum Member
Joined
Jun 16, 2014
Messages
8,808
Location
Cotati, Calif.
Over the past several months I have noticed on the PBS cooking shows, Cooks Illustrated and Cooks Country they have been baking cakes using the reverse creaming method. This method basically is mixing the dry ingredients together in a bowl first, then adding the softened butter or shortening and mixing it into the dry ingredients much like you would do if making a pie crust only you mix it in more thoroughly, until it resembles wet sand. Next mix the eggs and liquid ingredients together and add at once to the dry mixture, mix on low for 30 secs. then switch speed to med. and continue mixing for 2 mins., much like you would do with a cake mix. Bake just as you normally would. I have made my last 5 cakes this way and they really come out much better than using the traditional creaming method. It's really easy, almost as easy as a cake mix. I haven't even bothered to drag down the big Kitchen Aid stand mixer, I just us my Kitchen Aid hand mixer. Here is the basic yellow cake recipe I devised, I have adapted it to make Chocolate, Burnt Sugar and Spice Cake as well.

2/3 cup butter, not unsalted, softened
2 cups AP flour
1 Tbs. baking powder
1/2 tsp. salt
1 1/2 cups granulated sugar
3 large eggs, room temp.(this really makes a difference)
1 cup whole milk, room temp
1 tsp. vanilla

I bake this batter in 2 - 8" cake pans ( I have WIlton pans, they are a littlle deeper). I spray the pans with cooking spray, line the bottoms with wax paper and spray again, Bake at 350 F for approx. 30-33 mins.
Cool in pans on a rack for 10 mins. then turn out of pans and cool thoroughly before frosting.

For enough batter to make 2 - 9" layers or 3 - 8" layers just increase butter to 1 cup, flour to 3 cups, sugar to 2 cups, baking powder to 4 tsp., salt to 3/4/ tsp., 4 eggs instead of 3, milk tp 1 1/3 cups, and vanilla to 1 1/2 tsp.

I always make my own butter cream frosting using the basic recipe on the powdwered sugar bag, I don't measure, but I do increase the amounts to 1 1/2 lbs powdered sugar and butter to 3/4 cup and I use 1/2&1/2 instead of milk, I eyeball the amount of liquid until its the right consitancy. Of course I also add vanilla or another flavoring. This gives a generous amount of frosting. For chocolate frosting add approx. 1/3 cup cocoa ( or more to taste )

I have attached some picures below.
Eddie[this post was last edited: 8/25/2016-00:02]

ea56-2016082421461701239_1.jpg

ea56-2016082421461701239_2.jpg
 
I do both, regular and reverse

creaming, especially when I am developing a cake. It works well for quick breads, like banana bread.

However, if I am happy with the results, like a Dorie Greenspan or Rose Levy Berenbaum cake, I don't change a thing.

I would be very interested in your burnt sugar variation.

Lawrence/Maytagbear
 
Lawrence

for a Burnt Sugar cake caramelize 1 cup granulated sugar over med heat, when it reaches a dark golden brown add 1 cup boiling water, reduce heat and boil for 10 mins to reduce to a syrup like consistency. For the Burnt Sugar cake use 1/2 cup of the Burnt Sugar syrup and 1/2 cup milk. Use the remainder for all or part of the liquid when making the frosting. This is a delicious old time cake. My husband David loves this cake.

ea56-2016082500450005186_1.jpg

ea56-2016082500450005186_2.jpg
 
This is basically like what a cake mix is: dry ingredients combined then the liquid ingredients are added. I used to use this method when making pound cakes in my Cuisinart. It worked very well, but I had to add a little baking powder because not as much air was incorporated into the batter.
 
tyring to cut back on sugar. Down to one soft drink a day and cut out snacking and desserts. Life without dessert sucks, I will say that.
 
I cut out all diet soda's

except when I eat out, and then I mostly order iced tea. Our bodies break down all carbohydrates into sugars. It is the fuel the body burns first, and needs. Of course too much is no good.
That's why cutting carbs, especially simple carbs can help us lose weight.
Complex carbs burn slower, and don't cause the hunger cravings associated with a sugar rush and crash.
Eliminating as many carbs as possible forces the body into ketosis. (Adkins diet) More weight loss happens, but not with out side effects. Headaches being the most.
It's not for everyone. Some experience higher cholesterol from the extra consumption of meat proteins. Some have trouble staying on it, and when returning to normal carbohydrate intake, gain the weight back. So I say moderation is the answer.
 
I whole heartedly agree with Mike. Moderation is really the answer to long term success with weight control. Also realizing that maybe being a little overweight is better than yo-yo dieting up and down. I have fought my weight since I was 10 yrs old and over the course of my lifetime I've easliy lost and gained the equivalent of maybe 4 adults. I finally gave up dieting per say 3 yrs ago. But I've cut my portion sizes back, no second helpings, no sugar based sodas (but 3 diet ginger ales on the weekend). I eat whatever I want, but less and cook with less fat. On our 3 weekend days I splurge and have dessert, but sensible size portions. During the week I eat lighter and have fruit for dessert. Over the past 3 yrs I've gone from a high of 215 to 170 and I know that this will finally be a permanent weight loss. So I say unless you are diabetic or have other major health concerns just cut back, eat the things you like, just less of them and less often. You may be pleasantly surprised that you'll stop binge eating and feel better and slowly lose your extra weight. I'm 65 now, I know that its unrealistic for me to ever weigh 130 again and have a 30 inch waist. But I can be perfectly happy at 160-165 with a 34 inch waist at 5"6". It may be slightly overweight, but a darn sight better that better than 215 with a 40+ inch waist and XL shirts. That's why I make good homemade desserts, so when I do splurge its on something that I'll enjoy. Then on Monday its back to fruit for dessert. My doctor agrees with my plan and it's been successful. BTW, I do weigh myself daily, at the same time with the same amount of clothing. If I'm up a lb. I cut back that day and its all good.
Eddie
 
I used to drink a lot of Pepsi, Squirt, 7up, Sunkist Orange and Vernor's Gingerale plus and occasional Coke.  I'd have a 20oz Pepsi with my dinner, and drink one of the others with lunch or through the day.  Stopped it about a year ago, and it's rare to even crave it.  I bought a 12 pack of Coke because it was on sale and it lasted well over 2 months, no real desire for it.

 

How did I do it?  For me it was the Soda Stream.  When it came down to it it was the carbonation I carved not the flavor or the sugar.  Now I do a liter or two of carbonated water a day, often with fresh lemon or fresh lime -- NEVER that bottled crap and I'm satisfied.  I dumped 300-400 calories a day and did not even miss it.

 

The cake looks good, I'll save the recipe and make it at some point, thanks.
 
@ea

first, sorry to the OP for the thread jack.

Completely agree. I'm maybe 15-20 overweight, but I'm not just overtly big.

One of the reasons I decided to cut back is that I'm in my late 40's and I just don't feel good alot of the time. Cutting back has helped definitely (though not my mood).
 
Hey Artcurus no need for an apology. I'm glad that cutting back has helped you. You're still young, being in your late 40's. Sounds like you are on the right track. Keep taking good care of yourself.
Eddie
 
Eddie, Your cake looks so good. I love home made cakes and spend time trying different recipes. I will try this one this weekend. I am eating less and mostly good quality food and things I want in moderation. I have lost 12 lbs in the past couple of months. My mother always said its not what you eat, but how much you eat. Like Louis it is calories in and calories out. I do feel better. I looked up the Beattys cake Mike and now have that in my file. I love a good chocolate cake with coffee in them. Thanks for sharing guys and have a good weekend. Dano
 
Dano

thanks for the complement! Sounds like you are doing well with your moderation plan. If you like things with a caramel flavor be sure to try the Burnt Sugar cake, it is our favorite. And if you can make it a day ahead for some reason it seems to taste even better the day after its baked.
Eddie
 
Speaking of creaming, was once told it's preferable to add coffee to cream than add cream to coffee.  Also not to hard-boil tea or coffee water, makes it taste 'flat'.
 
Louis is correct

burning more calories than we take in will result in weight loss. Dr. Oz also says this.
Food today to Americans in particular is an excess even my own parents didn't have as a luxury other than on holidays or a special occasion. The great depression, and WW2 were hard times.
Poorer people eat a worse diet with more processed foods today. They cost less, and that stretches the budget of which many are on government assistance for food.
Few of us have the time needed to cook wholesome meals at home. More work hours, less leisure time. Restaurants are jam packed. They even were last decade during the great recession. Larger portions at some. Too much sugar, sodium, pink curing salt, no control of the ingredients, unless you order off the heart smart lean menu.
So the world is losing the battle of type 2 diabetes, and obesity. We must make time for exercise, as most occupations today are in a chair at a desk. I hope they find a cure very soon.
 
@vacerator,

Dr Oz is a quack, pretty much. He dispenses bad and "fad" medical advice. That being said, something changed in the food supply starting in the 80's. whether it be the explosion of HFCS. (this chemical is literally in EVERYTHING, I've even found it in canned tomato sauce), chemicals that can't be pronounced and other things. You are correct.

I've been watching video on youtube that have this guy that eats old Military rations, the ingredients on these old rations can be very clearly read most of the time, and you can literally see the history of additives as the years go by. The early ones, say, for a cake, only contain only the very basic ingredients, flour, sugar, etc.

The other problem is what's called "food deserts". Many grocery chains will not go into poorer neighborhoods, so the only option is convenience stores or fast food. I will give Wal Mart props for this because they have been trying.
 
Others also say

Dr. Oz is a quack. I've known a few way worse. Perhaps it's matter of opinion, but he offers some very good advice for better health. Eating nuts for example.
Doctors practice medicine, they are not always miracle workers. They learn along the way like we all do.
The first doctor at John Hopkins hospital in Baltimore to use anesthesisa became addicted to the cocaine he used for it.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top