Simply Washing Detergents

Automatic Washer - The world's coolest Washing Machines, Dryers and Dishwashers

Help Support :

liberatordeluxe

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 15, 2012
Messages
530
Location
UK
Does anyone know if Aquados are still making Simply washing detergents? Sainsbury's don't seem to sell the liquids and very little of the powders anymore. I liked the range and thought it was good value and good perfomance. Anyone ever use the brand and how did they rate it?
 
I had a couple of tubs of the Simply Bio soft tabs a few years ago when they came out; the formulation was phosphate based and they smelled very pleasant. The performance was adequate. I felt they left the clothes a bit rough after a while compared to other powders.

Then, about 18 months ago, I bought a tub of their sensitive non-bio soft tabs. The formulation had changed to remove the phosphate base. The result of this was horrendous white streaks on laundry and a crusty deposit on the washer drum that required treatment with neat vinegar to remove. The streaks on the clothes didn't wash out well either! Actual washing performance was again adequate, but the side effects mean I'd be unlikely ever to buy a tub again.

Of course, things may have changed and maybe I had a bad batch, but my advice should you wish to try them - the powder tabs at any rate - is to use them on whites only. I haven't tried any of their liquid products.
 
The last few weeks have seen me using a bottle of Ecover gel; I have to say I quite like it - it's the first gel I've tried. It makes a nice base detergent and the fragrance is pleasing - surprisingly lingering in fact. Like any liquid it will do nicely for darks but you need to build it to wash whites or lights with stains, so I'm using up the tubs of Vanish and Ariel stain remover powders (bought on a whim) when the load calls for it.

Before the Ecover gel I'd been using Surcare powder for whites and lights (again with the stain removers on occasion) and Method liquid for darker colours; the Method was picked up out of curiosity and a deal to get it free. It cleaned well enough and smelt alright, though I wouldn't rave about it.

Upstairs in detergent overspill cupboard I'm waiting to crack open a box of Ecover non-bio powder. I tried it when the new formulation came out about a year or so ago - lovely smell, relatively good cleaning but made too much foam (suds to the middle of the door which makes my machine leak from the seal slightly). I'm wondering if it's still as sudsy. As it happens, I dropped a line to Ecover about their gel and whether it had any water softening agents (apparently not, but that's another topic) and as a second point said their powder had been too sudsy. I mentioned that I'd read somewhere on their site the dosing guide was designed for 6kg machines whereas I only have the older 5kg capacity; it seems I need to knock back the dose to medium instead of hard water...although, on the box I've bought it says the instructions are for 4-5kg machines...so someone's confused!

 

There's no particular reason why I use the environmentally friendly or slightly more gentle detergents - I'm not alergic to the stronger stuff. I just like the idea of them. On a cost basis I certainly can't commend my choices, but with only a couple of loads a week on average there are quicker and more rewarding ways to save 50p!
 
I think the reason why detergents over foam now is because phosphates have been removed however Simply does not overfoam. I don't think the detergents that are currently on sale are suitable for our energy efficient washing machines but you can't tell the detergent or washer manufacturers that as they blame it on you over dosing lol The rows i have had with Comet and Bennetts over this and Ariel!
 
Bloody laptops, i meant the range of detergents suitable are not really suitable for our modern washers because of foaming issues.
 
Our Sainsbury's have Simply non bio powder tabs and the Simply pure ones plus Simply liquitabs, I haven't seen Simply bio for a long time.

I tried method but was not impressed. Have never tried Surcare as it has now perfume, bleaching agents or OBA's. I have tried Ecover products in the past but wasn;t overly keen on the fragrance.

Liberator, if you are a fan of Liquids try Halo non Bio, they have phosphates, rinse out easily and are anti-bacterial/ anti-fungal. You can get the Non Bio sports wash in Saindsbury's for £3.99 and you can in fact use it on all laundry. I use it for hubby's waterproofs and cycling gear that can't be washed at high temps.

 
Ill give it a try. You 100% certain it won't make my coloured clothing fade due to the OBA's? Funnily enough i don't like the fragrance of Ecover and it smells sickly when dried which isn't pleasant.
 
foaming

Having re-traced my thinking, I remember the issue of excessive suds was the reason I ended up on the Surcare: it's a very low-sudsing detergent (powder and liquid). It's not that I object to the sight of suds in the wash, but I don't want the drum half-full of foam given the potential for leakage on my machine.

 

Surcare powder itself actually isn't too bad at all, depending on what you want it to do. It's absolutely fine for anything where you need general cleaning, especially in hotter water - e.g. sheets and towels. Loads with trickier stains or those washed at lower temperatures need a helping hand with some stain remover. It does contain optical brighteners but has no perfume: this is where it can be a bit of a scary prospect. What you get, however, is laundry that smells clean in a soda and oxygen bleach way; in fact, it's a refreshing experience especially if you've dried things outside, and you can slip between clean sheets without wondering whether all that perfume you'd normally get is actually a bit on the toxic side!

 

Overall, I do quite like the idea of washing with a reduced cocktail of chemicals which is why I keep coming back to the likes of Ecover, Surcare or Method. I can't pretend, however, that they're as effective as mainstream premium brands. The idea is perhaps only to bring out the bigs guns when they're needed!
 
I am going to try Halo as suggested by PaulC. I do think Unilever and Procter and Gambles detergent are way too foamy and i have written to them about it but they are not interested. Why people have an obsession with seeing suds is beyond me. They don't prove that the product is cleaning and quite the opposite inhibits cleabning if too mucgh.
 
Why people have an obsession with seeing suds is beyond me

I agree. There is nothing more difficult to rinse out that a load of suds. Having said that, if there were no suds at all, it wouldn't feel right either. I like to see a little bit of foam running down the door as machine tumbles, but not so much that there is a thick, white layer ontop of the wash water. I've never had a problem with excess foaming using Persil. Aldi's Almat is great for low suds too - sepcially the colour powder.
 
I am not a fan of Persil liquids at the moment because the colour liquid gives me a headache. Its too perfumed but the colour care powder, liqui tabs and bio powder smells less potent lol.
 
If you want a simple detergent, I found Persil non bio small and mighty a good all-purpose detergent, again you can build it up with oxy bleach for whites etc but it is a great general detergent on lightly to normally soiled loads.

 

I still maintain that Almat is the best detergent out there at the moment though - only small doses needed, rinses well and cleans brilliantly and only needs 50ml for most loads.

 

Of course in amongst my stash I also have hoards of Persil bio and colour in liquids, powders and liquid capsules... enough to wash for an army until next year!

 

Jon
 
I love Almat, but sadly, my washing machine doesn't. I've had a few problems with it not flushing into the drum properly and solidifying inside the dispenser. Only Almat Bio powder does this - no other bio or Almat colour does it. I know a few others who have had similar issues - anybody else experienced this? Have Aldi resolved the issue yet?
 
Almat bio powder clumping in the drawer?

Yes, yes and yes! My Mother uses it and it's abysmal in that respect. You can even pour a kettle of boiling water over the clump and it still won't completely wash out. I had a look in the dispenser one day and thought she must have terminated a load at filling...not so!

 

Admittedly noone's broken out in a rash or anything, and the clothes aren't in a state even though all the rinse water flows through those clumps of powder. Nonetheless, on that principle alone, Almat bio powder will not be going in my washer's dispenser again if I have anything to do with it!
 

Latest posts

Back
Top