Somebody Help Me...Stinky dishwasher

Automatic Washer - The world's coolest Washing Machines, Dryers and Dishwashers

Help Support :

If the techs have already increased the final rinse temp... the only thing else I can think of is to have them activate the 2nd rinse function and/or the extra water function.

Maybe a Miele tech can come out and borrow a smelly glass from you and take it to the lab to analyse what's going on?

At least we know now, since the clean glasses load didn't stink, it's not the rinse aid, detergent or the machine that itself smells. Must be something to do with the soil not being removed - I suppose.
 
See, I have talked with the neighbors, I live in a town house , there are 177 homes here....the builder installed plastic tub models.  I had the Profile, but was plastic.  None of the neighbors seem to have be complaining.  I went to the neighbors and asked to have a glass of water while I was there to check it out and there was no smell.

 

I went to Lowes today and bought the Whirlpool Gold, plastic tub....it is washing a load now, I hoping it works.    I found

 

My Miele was only the 1600.00 one it doesn't have the salt system.

 

I truly appreciate all the advise...I will admit I am really bummed about this....but I am truly at a loss...I just hope this cheap one cleans and doesn't smell...

 

this is what I bought...

 

http://www.lowes.com/pd_362071-46-WDT710PAYM_0__?productId=3546992&Ntt=whirlpool+dishwasher&pl=1¤tURL=%2Fpl__0__s%3FNtt%3Dwhirlpool%2Bdishwasher&facetInfo=#BVRRWidgetID
 
23.875 ???

Not 24 "  23.875 ??? C'mon now.

 

Overnight Soak Cycle ?  Pretty soon there will be a 2 day extended wash with 1/2 a cup of water for Heavily Soiled Dishes. I apologize for the sarcasm, but it never ends.  I guess I'm getting too old to understand some of this nonsense. (As it appears to me).

 

I do wish you the best of luck with this machine. Too bad the Miele couldn't be remedied.
 
The remedy might have been easy if the poster had not posted the problem the day before going out to buy a new one. We were supposed to have the answer immediately. We can learn from this that often people do not want help as much as they want sympathy; more than a solution, they want to get everyone excited about their problem. Why could this person not tell us on 2/17 that they were going to buy a new dishwasher on 2/18? Most of us here are men and it is our first impulse to solve problems when someone writes in with an appliance situation. Maybe we need to begin with the question, "Have you already decided to replace the machine?" This is far more diplomatic than asking if they want help or sympathy or just want others to get upset also.

Asking for a glass of water at the neighbors was not a bright way of researching the problem because the water you drink is cold while the water for the dishwasher is from the water heater.
 
One thought that comes to mind that I have not seen mentioned is sewer gas.  If the vent stack is partially blocked, or depending on how the wind blows sewer gas may be getting into the system.  Kind of a long shot, but it seems nothing else has shown up.  If the problem continues with a new machine I'd certainly look into that as a cause.
 
I also think it is sewer gas. Easy test for this do not use the dishwasher for a few days and leave the door closed. Then open and that a smell. This happen to a person I know let me say it smells well like poop. lol

But this is also very dangers very very dangers. Sewer gas well and can become a flash fire very scary stuff.

Few other things does this sink where it is hooked to have a p trap. I know you might think duh yes it dose, but I have seen homes where they did not use them to save money.

If you think you got a sewer gas back up get a person out there fast before something happens. Same thing can happen with a hot water heater if not used for so long they can build up gas that also becomes a flash fire.
 
"I guess I'm getting too old to understand some of t

Same here. A dishwasher with an overnight cycle is the apex of idiocy. The only way to remedy this nonsense is to buy a commercial machine that has to do its job quickly and effectively. Domestic appliance design has clearly succumbed to political and social agendas that are no longer concerned with purpose, function and pragmatism; and it has nothing to do with intelligent environmentalism either.
 
The thing that is most over looked is the rinse aid. Too much can cause this smell.
If the level is not set to the lowest level and with the use of detergent with rinse aid this can ba an over kill.
Since you've changed your dishwasher, apply this solution to prevent this from happening again.
 
HI <span style="font-size: x-small;"><span style="font-family: Arial;"> <a name="startPOSTER_38869.33"></a>Tomturbomatic  I understand what you are saying...I have not given up on the dishwaher,  I gave up on the smell of dirty dishes,  I have hooked it up in the laundry room....I just can't keep having all my dishes stink....I have ran the dishes through the new dishwasher and no smell what so ever.  I hate the way it loads  esp after having the miele...it is going from the top of the line to the bottom.....I hate the plastic tub, but all the google post seem to have the trouble with stainless, I read about chemical reaction between water and chemicals and stainless.  I just need to keep focused and working on this...I hooked the Miele to both hot and cold water, same result, I have used all the rinse aid with all different setting....I keep trying and open to more things to try, the miele repair man has been here 3 times, took the entire thing apart.  I truly don't know  what to do.</span></span>
 
rinseaid

I have tried the rinse aid, I have tried the rinse aid at all levels, I have used just white vinegar in the, I have tried all the brands.  The Miele Tech did check that as well...he had mention that that is why for a month I used the white vinegar...same results....someone else mention the sewer gas, have connected it all different ways....to the airgap, to the disposal, I even let it drain in a big bucket for a week to see if it would change it....
 
It is quite possible that it was only that machine.

If it had been me, I would have requested a replacement machine from Miele. You did say that your Miele was relatively new and clearly still under warranty. In fact, after three service calls, that would have been the next step for me. Stainless steel is the least likely material to react to dishwashing chemicals and either generate or retain odors. As I've said before and based on the info you've provided, it is quite possible that something didn't go quite right during the manufacturing process of you machine. You also said that you didn't have this issue from word go, but that it occurred two to three months after you began using it. You may also have to wait a while with your replacement dishwasher before this problem manifests.
 
My midline Bosch dishwasher used to have an off smell. I found it started happening when Costco's Kirkland detergent switched from a chlorinated phosphated to a non-chlorinated enzyme type of phosphated detergent. I switched to Cascade enzyme/phosphated and the problem went away.

Occasionally when an odor happens I'll check the filter and find that it is a bit on the dirty side (usually some sort of slime).

It's possible that there is something wrong with the dishwasher - the rinse cycle should be removing all traces of detergent/soil. Sometimes objects in the dishwasher can block the spin of the wash arms that would impede washing and rinsing efficiency. It's always a good idea to check the wash arms after loading to make sure they can spin freely.
 
Do you use "Rinse & Hold"?

I don't use the cold rinse option to rinse the partial load, because I noticed that it left my Bosch machine smelly until the wash cycle was started in the evening.

Extremely dirty stuff gets rinsed under the cold tap, then placed in the machine. An AutoSuperwash cycle gets run 99.99% of the time, and everything comes out fine.
 
KUDS22

Steve I would like to talk with you more about that.  I have emailed from my [email protected] email. 

 

I didn't see another way to contact you.

 

I returned the Whirlpool, it was junk didn't clean and hated loading it.  I still have the Miele hooked up in the laudry room trying different things.  The repairman came on Friday, pulled the pump and it is spotless.  He is says in the 17 years he has been doing this...this is the first one he can't figure out....He says my machine is perfect and that it isn't the machine.  I don't know about that.  I had the Stainless KitchenAid for 2 years and it never ever smelled (just went through 3 control boards)

 

I bought a used KUDS23 from a older couple that are remodeling and it is working very well.  However I am very interested in talking with you about yours.

 

Thanks AJ

 

 

 

 
 
Might it be the rubber door seal/gasket or even the adhesive for the gasket? I have always thought Miele DW smelled a little funny when I've viewed them at the store. If it isn't water stagnating or hidden food particle buildup somewhere, then it has to be something else. Check out the door seal...
 
plumbing and door seal

I had a plumber come and it was installed correctly with high loop to the disposal.  I said is there anything else we can do to make sure this isn't the problem, he installed an "AirGap"it is a funny looking thing that I had to pay a granite guy to drill a hole in the granite that the dishwasher drains into, it drains up then down.  No Change. 

 

The door seal is clean and doesn't seem to have a smell.

 

It is never the dishwasher that has the odor, it always what I take out, you can smell it on the load of dishes as they cool inside the machine, like if you open the door when it done, grab a glass no smell, then wait 5 mins so you can handle them they begin to smell....same with dinner plates...very odd. 

 

I have not had any issues with the New (old) kitchen aid KUDS23, before the Miele I had the Stainless Kitchen never had a smell, had it for 2 years...just replaced control boards (3 of them) before that when I moved in the builder installed a plastic tub GE Profile, never smelled just didn't clean.
 
burned by heating element?

Shouldn't imagine so. I think Miele machines now use hidden "through flow" heaters.

Could the smell be caused by production processes on the plastic components? I have experienced in the distant past, an odour like mothballs (naphthalene) from some UK manufactured vacuum cleaners.
 
I think it has been discovered....

I have left the machine hooked in the laundry room to the cold water and have been bring the dishes to it.  I notice the smell in the new (old ) KitchenAid......I damn near had a stroke.  It is the hot water heater, it is 6 years old and something called anode is going.  I had a plumber here today.  He said yes that is what causing the "fishy" smell....I explained that it is only in the dishwasher, he said that is common just one area.  I am so glad to have figured it out and I am very happy that all of you helped me.  Thanks for all the ideas....
 
Great news!

I was confident that it couldn't be the dishwasher. Most dishwashers in Australia are hooked up to cold water and the machine heats it to the selected temperature. Saying that I have mine connected to hot water, but I have a high efficiency gas flow through heater, therefore there is no tank. I have never experienced any smell whether connected to cold or hot.
I think the problem too is that now because of being more environmentally friendly, hot water systems are set below 140 degrees which could lead to these problems as the water is not hot enough to prevent bacterial growth in the tank.
 
That's interesting to learn that the odor was caused by the hot water heater. I can't say we've ever noticed that problem with any of our hot water heaters. I know the anode was completely gone in our old one when it began to leak out the bottom. We keep our water heater running fairly hot, so perhaps that makes a difference.

In any event, it must be a relief to finally know the reason why.
 
I should have known

This is an all too common problem with water heaters under many water conditions. This smell is caused by a chemical reaction between the water and the sacrificial anode rod. This happens to prevent the chemical reaction from degrading the lining of the tank or it's metal fittings. The most common result is water that smell like sewer gas, rotten eggs, or sour fish. The remedy is to have an anode installed that is made of an alternate material.
 
If it is the hot water causing the odour then why can you not smell it when the water is running at a faucet or when taking a shower - why is it only affecting the dishwasher? I get my water from a well and it sometimes has a sulphur odour which I can detect at every faucet.

Gary
 
Wow, so I was looking around the site and came across this old thread.. I've had this problem with my old Bosch and my current Miele LaPerla. I'm going to check out my water heater - I would be ecstatic if this fixed this particular issue with my machine - dishes coming out smelling like fish!

I've tried everything else up to this point.. I know that the machine is clean, I know it's not a drain issue, I've tried different detergents, different rinse aids, even a phosphate detergent that I found online.
 
Before you have the plumber come out, read my reply #28 above. If your heater uses a magnesium anode, see if you can have the plumber substitute an aluminum one. That often solves the problem. Also make sure that the water heater is set to 140F because of the bacteria mentioned in the article I posted. Best of luck.
 
Wow!

I just read through this entire post. I'm exhausted.........

I knew it was a long one and as I paged down and it kept getting more mysterious only to find out it was the hot water heater......

WOW.........that's kind of freaky & odd that it only smells in the dishwasher.........I keep mine set at 140
 

Similar threads

G
Kenmore Dishwasher Rant!
Replies
0
Views
343
gelaundry4ever
G
jjsunshine
KitchenAid dishwasher not cleaning well
Replies
6
Views
435
maytaga806
M
G
dishomat dreams and ideas
2 3 4
Replies
94
Views
2K
maytaga806
M
P
looking for the modern equivalent of a vintage kitchen aid dishwasher
Replies
15
Views
721
dtodd
D
D
My Whirlpool dishwasher
2 3
Replies
61
Views
1K
tolivac
T

Latest posts

Back
Top