We Just Cant Decide, ugh!

[toploader55]

I'm partial to Yellow...

I love the contrast in your kitchen with all the other colors. Seems like the Yellow ties it all together.

Good Luck. It is a tough decision.

 

[danemodsandy]

Yellow!

It's a better "pop" in that part of the kitchen, and Pink in a major appliance always feels like the Department of the Excessively Girly to me anyway. Fine as a paint color, a fabric color or an accessory color, but not so much for durables.

P.S.: I envy you that nice Cuisinart CFP-4 or -5 on the mixer shelves. I have been looking for one for a while.

 

[frigilux]

Unlike some decorating decisions, there is no wrong answer here; either color works, albeit for different reasons. I'm trending pink. Pink works so well with the blue, and you get the tie-in with the KA directly across from it.

 

[foraloysius]

I flipped a coin for you. Pink it is!

That said, I think I prefer yellow, it looks a bit warmer.

 

[Unimatic1140]

I know, I know, such a hard decision. If we decide on the pink then the KitchenAid dishwasher across from it will have to go yellow as we don't want two major appliances to be the same color in the Kitchen, it throws everything off!

I also suggested a Pink control panel on the yellow range, but I got that spousal look from Fred that lovingly says "NO" lol.

Really not enough good parts to keep make two good ranges, one only good Automatic Calrod assembly between the three range, so only one range it is.

Ugh, I'm going to go do wash as I can't think about it. Such first world problems we have.

 

[NYCWriter]

I vote YELLOW ...

... to avoid being too lopsided with pink appliances.

 

[lovestowash]

You'll be "in the pink"...

with yellow...

George

 

[gansky1]

Pink is nice, but I always liked the yellow too.
So difficult!

 

[DirectDriveDave]

I'd say go with the yellow. Looks good with the wall that the clock is on! 

 

[dustin92]

I'm liking the pink! It really fits the kitchen and looks great with the pink dishwasher.

 

[jmm63]

Never show favortism

Find someplace to store one of them
6 Months with Yellow (I say Easter-Thanksgiving)
6 Months with Pink

 

[dynaflow]

All i can say is

Im pea green with envy

 

[mrb627]

Dr. bellows

Is anyone else reminded of the Jeannie episode where dr Bellows accidentally obtained Jeannie's powers. In a phone conversation with Amanda, they discussed the paint color of the house. Meanwhile, the painter is having his mind blown because the house color bounces back and forth. Eventually landing I a mix of yellow and green.

So, I vote for blending body parts from both ranges to get a mix of yellow and pink.

And in the words of Larry Hagman, "I wish you had my problem!"

Malcolm

 

[moparguy]

All I can say, is what a fabulous decision you have to make, either one is so beautiful you can't go wrong either way! How fortunate to have color options, most of the stoves that I find here are white.

 

[pulltostart]

I'm with Jim

Keep both and rotate the colors with the seasons.  Furthermore - why not keep your eyes out for a Woodtone Brown and a Turquoise model and REALLY rotate the colors with the seasons!

 

Actually, both colors look great with everything else in your kitchen. 

 

lawrence

 

[firedome]

i have to say Pink!

Here's our '56 Hotpoint, this thing is loaded with every feature known to man!
(Rotisserie, Temp probe, Custom Cooker, Supermatic w/ deep well, and plug-in Griddle not shown). And it goes better with our walls than the Yellow '58 GE we had.

Be nice to have the dilemna that you have Robert! I'd put the best parts on the one you decide on and keep the other... just in case!

 

[jeffg]

Robert, I prefer the pink, but in that room yellow looks better imo. Turquoise+yellow is a rare combo, turquoise+pink is unheard of.

Both gorgeous.

 

[strongenough78]

Since the yellow is a rare color, I'd stick with the yellow.

 

[polkanut]

I'm with Vern & Roger on this one.  Keep the yellow, and use the pink range as a parts donor.

 

[turquoisedude]

Yellow is not a colour we see up here that much, Robert, and I do recall how well the chocolate mousse I made on the yellow one turned out....