Wait a Minute!
You know I totally agree with Chris' post above. I just went back to your first post and reread it, it gives a very important clue which I didn't notice before:
"It seems as if it's the motor (regretfully). It spins with no issues but it just seems to have an issue agitating. "
***bangs head on wall for skimming thread for pictures and not reading properly***
As Chris stated, if a motor operates in one direction it can operate in the other direction. If the mechanism in not binding or hard to turn then starting the motor in agitation is much easier than starting the motor in spin. I've seen capacitor issues where the motor had trouble starting in spin and agitation was fine, but not the reverse (unless there are two separate starting capacitors like in the Frigidiare Super-Duty coin-ops). I'm pretty sure the problem most likely is in the timer now. The timer needs to reverse the neutral and hot leads to the motor in order to revere the direction, if one of the contacts on the spin side is dirty or burned it could cause this problem.
It might be time for a timer-ectamy?
You know I totally agree with Chris' post above. I just went back to your first post and reread it, it gives a very important clue which I didn't notice before:
"It seems as if it's the motor (regretfully). It spins with no issues but it just seems to have an issue agitating. "
***bangs head on wall for skimming thread for pictures and not reading properly***
As Chris stated, if a motor operates in one direction it can operate in the other direction. If the mechanism in not binding or hard to turn then starting the motor in agitation is much easier than starting the motor in spin. I've seen capacitor issues where the motor had trouble starting in spin and agitation was fine, but not the reverse (unless there are two separate starting capacitors like in the Frigidiare Super-Duty coin-ops). I'm pretty sure the problem most likely is in the timer now. The timer needs to reverse the neutral and hot leads to the motor in order to revere the direction, if one of the contacts on the spin side is dirty or burned it could cause this problem.
It might be time for a timer-ectamy?