Andrew, I can't say about the machine initially being "fine" as I didn't run it prior to disassembly for clean-up. I didn't expect to find the u-joint bad, and it was ... the basket hub had surface corrosion but otherwise looked to be intact. If I had done only superficial clean-up without disassembly, who knows how long it would have run until the u-joint froze completely ... or if the basket would have eventually separated from the hub or not. It *had* to been on the verge of failure, as I couldn't have whacked the spanner nut *that* hard when reassembling to cause the trouble. I'm a weakling, LOL, I've been sitting at a desk job for 8 years and I don't do gyms!
The u-joint kit instructions say there are two kinds of basket hubs used, and each takes a specific spanner nut. The hub and spanner number have embossed part numbers. There's a chart in the instructions for matching them. One new spanner nut is included with the u-joint kit, and it was the right one to match my basket hub. Further, there are different tightening instructions for the two hub/nut combos. Mine instructed to tighten the nut finger-tight, then another 1 to 1-1/4 turns with the wrench -- 135 ft/lb torque. Interestingly, it says if replacing the basket at the same time, tighten it ANOTHER 1 to 1-1/4 (or 1-1/2?) turns!
This 2nd machine that looks cosmetically nearly pristine has turned into a serious headache. I suppose if one decides to break into a Calypso mechanism, one must be prepared to go the distance. Since the flange of the spanner nut protrudes below the hub threads into the u-joint, I may end up damaging the new u-joint when cutting the nut off and have to get another one.
A loose hub must be what is Jackson's trouble. Maybe not loose to the same degree, but with the same symptoms -- excessive oscillation during spin and the u-joint/hub turning when attempting to remove the spanner nut.