Pulled Pork (gas grill)
I know this would be better with a charcoal grill or in a true smoker, but with the gas grill I can leave it alone all day while we're at Brimfield!
Start the day before with an 8-10# pork shoulder. Score the skin and fat cap (but not the meat) in a diamond pattern. Prepare the rub:
- 3T paprika
- 2T granulated garlic
- 4T dark brown sugar
- 2T ground dry mustard
- 2T Kosher salt
- 2T chili powder
- 1/2T ground pepper
- 1/2T cinnamon
- 1/2T liquid smoke
Mix everything together, and add just enough water until a paste forms, the consistancy of tomato paste. Massage the rub into the pork and store in a ziplock in the fridge at least overnight.
For a gas grill (makes it very easy) put a disposable foil cookie sheet under the main cooking grate. If you have 4 burners, put the sheet in the middle. If you have 2-3, put it far to one side. If you have a smoke box, fill it with dry chips (I use apple) and put it on the burner hood/flavorizer bar under the cooking grate if it fits. Light the outside burners if you have 4, or one side, opposite the pork, if you have 2 or 3. The smoke box goes over a lit burner. Ideally you're looking for about 250-260 degrees. I have 4 burners and if I leave the two outer ones on the lowest setting, it maintains well.
Leave the pork on there for about 8-9 hours. Fat will drip into the cookie sheet as the pork cooks. If you want to, carefully change the wood in the smoke box a couple of times if it burns out. If you have an instant-read thermometer, you're looking for about 175-180 degrees.
At some point during the cooking, make the sauce:
- 28oz can tomato puree
- 1/2 can frozen OJ
- 1c white vinegar
- 1c dark brown sugar
- 1T granulated garlic
- 1t liquid smoke
Bring all ingredients to a boil, and simmer for about an hour. The sauce should be relatively thin and a little sweet, but with a little vinegar tang. Add a little more brown sugar or vinegar as needed because all tomato sauces have a little different sweetness to them. Remember, I don't usually measure with stuff like this so these are approximate. If you need to adjust to taste, do it!
When the pork is done, carefully pull it off the grill. Discard the fat and skin (well, some people chew on pieces of the crispy skin while they pull the pork). Take 2 forks and shred the meat. Add sauce to taste. The pork should be more damp than wet, and not sloppy. You want the sauce to add to the pork flavor, not overpower it. Extra sauce can be served on the side or frozen for the next time you make this. Keep the pork tightly covered and warm until serving time. A foil chafing pan and aluminum foil is great for this, and it can go back on the grill with indirect heat if you want. The pork can be eaten as-is with a fork, or on buns.
I know this may sound like a lot of work, but it's really not hard, and it's a lot of fun to have someone there to help! Our cousin Mary Jane is always ready to help me pull my pork! (You didn't expect me to let this whole thing go without at least ONE pork-pulling quip, did you?)
Chuck