Food Fads: Enough Already!

Automatic Washer - The world's coolest Washing Machines, Dryers and Dishwashers

Help Support :

That Fanny takes the cake for being an arrogant and pompous beetch.  Wouldn't it have been fun if the poor girl who's winning recipe she cut to shreds had slightly used stronger words. She'd probably be famous herself afterwards. 
 
Actually....

"She'd probably be famous herself afterwards."

Actually, she was for a bit. Gwen Troake, the housewife whose menu was savaged, was defended by other British foodies, and was given a chance to publish a cookbook, which she did. The cookbook (The Country Cookbook, 1977) did well, partly because it was a good cookbook and partly because of the publicity - and widespread public sympathy - Fanny had inadvertently given Troake.
 
Rachel Ray on Saltines and Celeb Chefs hocking pans

I'm sure I'll catch a load of flack for this, but as someone who does a LOT of cooking, and not always from recipes, Rachel's been a help; at least with her 30-Minute Meals (not the other shows where she visits fru-fru places, International destinations, and the like). She has a good sense of basic cooking and adapting to different situations, and developing/teaching shortcuts.

Where I feel she's gone downhill is pandering to the Food Network's desire to get popular personalities to host multiple shows, some of which have nothing to do with the personalities original show. Well that and whoring herself out to cookware manufacturers. I'll still stand by 30-Minute Meals.

I can't think of any of Martha's shows I'd stand by.

And if we're talking about "celeb" chefs on TV... Sara Moulton? She hosted 'Sara's Secrets,' and her only secret was probably how she got that job! This is the woman who said you should wipe your hands along the side of your chef's knife to remove onion smell (in reference to using the stainless steel block sold for that reason). What about rubbing them on the side of the sink? Maybe, just maybe, much safer than rubbing them on the knife!!!

Guy Fieri? Never learned anything from his cooking, but I've gotten ideas from the places he's visited on Diners, Drive Ins and Dives.

No ideas I can remember from Michael Chiarello, Paula Deen (though she's such a Southern mother figure), Ina Garten, and others who have 'successful' shows.

As far as celebs putting names on pans and the like, Puck and others did it before Ray and Emeril. Don't buy them for who's hocking them. Check the reviews! I bought a set of Calphalon Professional nonstick (retail $550) for 1/2 price, and they were the worst pans I ever bought. However, I love my Calphalon tri-ply copper and misc. branded enamel over cast iron from MArshall's and Home Goods!

Chuck
 
Food Network...

After seeing Emeril try to make biscuits,,,LOL,,,I was thru!! Paula was ok to start with, but most of her recipes ive tried were nOT all that, I will stick to my old cookbooks,Nancy Welch, Betty Feezor and Julia Child.
 
As for cookware!!!

If it says CHINA on it I put it back!! But seriously, I never use anything new anyway, more often than not I use either Aristo Craft or Club Aluminum,and also saladmaster.I would not trade one piece of Aristo Craft for all the new cookware on the shelves!!
 
Actually....

It's easier and cheaper to buy decent cookware today than ever before. I spent most of the 1980s in the housewares biz, both on the buying end and teaching cooking. At that time, buying premium cookware was a very expensive proposition.

Today, whatever one's opinion about Chinese manufacture, it must be said that overseas manufacturers have made expensive processes affordable. In the 1970s, Cuisinart came out with its first tri-ply bottom cookware; a heavy aluminum disc was brazed onto the bottom of a stainless utensil, and then another disc of stainless brazed over that. The technique - outlandishly expensive then - gave wealthy consumers performance and easy-clean characteristics. Later, Cuisinart went to a copper ply instead of aluminum. A one-quart saucepan was around $55 back then.

This construction is now very widespread, in both aluminum and copper versions. It has even been improved upon with what is called a "full cap" base, meaning that the outer stainless layer now wraps around the edge of the copper or aluminum one, improving cleanability even more. You can find cookware like this at most discount stores, at very affordable prices.

There are still some things to avoid, though:

1) Non-stick. It's fine on a couple of inexpensive pans you can afford to replace readily. It's silly on expensive cookware, because it doesn't last any longer on an expensive pan than it does on a cheap one.

2) Glass lids. They're touted as "see-through," which they aren't; steam produced in cooking makes the feature fairly useless. They exist for one reason: You will break them sooner or later. When you do, you will almost always find that an exact replacement is no longer available. This makes you a little less happy with your cookware, hastening the day you will buy new cookware, which is what manufacturers want you to do.

Stainless ply-bottomed (or full cap) cookware is an excellent choice for your "base" cookware. You need other types of cookware for certain jobs - perhaps nonstick for eggs, enameled cast iron for slow simmers and braising, that kind of thing.

This is personal preference, but I don't personally recommend anodized cookware like original Calphalon. The anodized layer is prone to wear-through, and there's no way to renew it. Also, it's not happy in dishwashers; it's very resistant to acid so long as the anodized layer is not breached, but it's fairly sensitive to the alkali in dishwasher detergent. Alkali will turn the grey surface whitish, and can make it very prone to sticking. In fairness, I will say that people who understand the characteristics of anodized cookware and are willing to take good care of it can extend its life dramatically.

What do I use personally? Vintage aluminum-clad Farberware. James Beard used to say it was the most cookware for the money, a sentiment I totally agree with - it performed about equally with Cuisinart, at a quarter the price. I don't mind shining the bottom with a bit of Brillo. New Farberware (the "Classic" line) has a full cap base, making that unnecessary.

I am also very fond of Corning Ware - the real Pyroceram stuff.
 
In the late 70s publication A Cook's Catalog, Beard did indeed give Farberware high marks. The only gripe I have with the cookware is that the bottoms are slightly concave so they flatten out when heated. This works fine in skillets or when a Dutch Oven is heated to temperatures above the boiling point for searing, sauteeing, etc., but when you want to boil water, the base of the pan remains much cooler and does not flatten out to make really good contact with the surface unit.

I have some pieces of the original Cuisinart cookware with the beautiful wood handles. The aluminum bases were much gentler than the newer copper discs in that they put more mass between the heat and the food, but both perform well and are FLAT. I thought the detachable handle for the Au Gratin pans was so neat I had to buy one for the one pan I have.

In the 80s, John's definition of a YUPPIE was someone with a set of Calphalon hanging over a commercial gas range, both unused because they eat every meal out.
 
I think the fad I am seeing the most of right now is "Gluten Free". How is it the children of the "dough boys' suddenly can't tolerate gluten?

Then there is the Probiotics. Now even dog foods are gluten free with probiotics. How do you get probiotics in a slurry that is mostly animal entrails anyway?
 
When I was a teenager, Calphalon was my dream. I have no idea why, and the irony was that my cooking ability was seriously limited back then. I don't think I was conscious of the fact that it was hot cookware. Practical experience, years later, pretty much cured me of Calphalon. My big gripe: it's not the easiest cookware to clean. (Maybe my pan--bought used--had issues, but I've heard similar complaints from people who owned from new.) I also find irony in the flood of destroyed Calphalon that goes through Goodwill. So much for the cookware that was marketed as the last you'd ever buy....

Incidentally, is Calphalon still made? I know the name is still around, but I haven't seen the "original" style for sale new in years.
 
Since "classic" Farberware came up

I might as well ask something I've wondered off and on. Is it dishwasher safe? I seem to recall some old American pans (Revere, if I recall right) have issues with handles deteriorating in a dishwasher.
 
And in my question above about Farberware, I do mean, of course, Farberware of years gone by (like James Beard knew), not whatever is currently made.
 
John, have you tried vintage Magnalite cookware? We got several of these frypans and saucepans 30+ years ago from our families, and in spite of heavy use and occasional abuse they still look as good now as back then. I think it's some kind of aluminum/magnesium alloy rather than an anodized product, so there's nothing to scratch. They clean easier than anodized (or cast iron) because you can take steel wool to them without damage.
 
GHC Magnalite

We have a lot of Magnalite.  Dave used to be the chef around the house, so we bought a set of it on sale in the mid-80's.  I've since picked up a few more pieces at thrift stores or estate sales.  Although it can't go in the dishwasher, Magnalite is fairly easy to clean and holds up very well with proper care.  Far better than Calphalon.  It's close enough to non-stick for me, and IIRC the stuff came with a 100-year guarantee, gimmick that it may have been.  Magnalite is some seriously substantial cookware.

 

I just recently found a lightly used 12-inch Magnalite long-handle frying pan for $1.50 at Salvation Army and it immediately became my go-to item for sauteing or frying.  Our Dutch Oven is the other piece that sees a lot of use.  I always keep an eye out for more.  It's easy to identify a viable piece, even if it needs a good cleaning.  A little Bon Ami will usually make the stuff look like new.
 
totally agree with Sandy

about non-stick, glass lids, Chinese made, etc. Makes no sense to buy pricey non-stick, however would like to share a good find: in a Denver restaurant supply store we bought a Chinese made Non-stick 10" frying pan made by Winco, Model AFP-10NS, and so far it's holding up and cooks better than any I've used, including daughter's non-stick Calphalon (which got trashed). It's made for commercial use I presume, of good and heavy construction, and best of all only around $28. Highly recommend.

There was tri-ply heavy very high quality cookware as early as late 60s, it was West Bend's preminum brand Luster-Craft, not sold in stores. Very expensive but worth it, and with lifetime warranty. We've been using it for 42 years now, so we got our $$$s worth. Had a pan fall off a hook in a basement cellarway, fell down a flight of stairs, broke the real Bakelite (not thermo-plastic) handle. WB replaced the whole pot, no questions asked. Heavy construction and features "waterless" cooking due to precision fitting lids. Great stuff.
 
With nonstick, I'm wondering if the newer coatings made of some sort of ceramic might prove more durable than Teflon coatings. Not that I'm inclined to gamble a lot. For that matter, I'm not sure I'll ever have nonstick again. I phased it out years back partly out of concern about what the long range health effects of Teflon coatings might be. I miss nonstick sometimes, but not very often--I really don't miss it that much.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top