Since I was able to remove the entire pin by hand I opened up the wash arm support to see how it all went together. The pin has a knurled end where I assume it was originally pressed into the plastic housing but now that it is free it allows the weight of the wash arm to push it down through closing off the water supply path. I found a previous post from stevet detailing how the lower nylon bushing sometimes comes loose and water pressure causes it to close off the port but my bottom bushing seems secure. I am planning on using some epoxy to reattach the pin inside the plastic housing. The housing isn't cracked and when the pin in inserted it doesn't wobble. I assume the expansion and contraction of all the hot water finally caused it to come loose. I can see the marks inside the plastic housing hole where the pin was normally seated and it looks to be almost flush with the bottom of the plastic housing. I hope this fix will hold until I can get a replacement. I noticed most pictures I have found have a nylon upper bushing where the wash arm rests but mine is brass for some reason. I have posted some pics to show what I am dealing with.

