Goudy Old Style Italic?
I can't hazard a guess as to what typeface Maytag used for the timer dial, but the selector buttons appear to be Goudy Old Style Italic:
www.myfonts.com
I can't hazard a guess as to what typeface Maytag used for the timer dial, but the selector buttons appear to be Goudy Old Style Italic:

Goudy Old Style Std Bold Italic Font | Webfont & Desktop | MyFonts
Goudy Old Style Font: Inspired by the Froben capitals believed to have been cut by Peter Schoeffer the Younger, son of Gutenberg’s apprentice, this design is...
