The Helical was more mechanically complex but the Orbital was made out of plastic. The Helical strained more when overloaded and the Orbital dealt better when overloaded. It's pretty much a tie IMHO, the best is putting a Powerfin agitator in a Orbital machine though, shortens the life of the transmission, but MAN does it move some clothes! It's like a KitchenAid agitator but on HIGH speed!!!