Need Advice on Types of Bathroom Vanity Sink Tops

[rp2813]

I'm replacing a '70s bathroom vanity with something new that has a retro look more compatible with the 1961 period of the room.  The new vanity didn't come with a top (it was NIB at the ReStore -- 80% off retail), and because it's not a common size (49 x 19), I have to buy one on line, sight unseen except for a picture because no brick and mortar retailers carry it. 

 

The companion top from the vanity's manufacturer is way too expensive to consider, and they only sell to contractors anyway.

 

The sink top I've chosen is a composite material and available in two types:  "Sleeved top" and "Box top."  I can't see any difference in them, even on their specifications pages.

 

Can anyone enlighten me on what the difference is?  I've e-mailed the manufacturer but it has been a few days and haven't received a reply, and I want to get on with this.

 

[circlew]

Ralph, I would suggest staying away from "cultured marble", as it doesn't hold up well for long. The glossy coating tends to crack and peel off.

A solid surface material (Corian, etc.) is much better, and easier to care for. It is, as you know, more expensive.

 

[rp2813]

Tom, I agree, but this bathroom sees very little use.  We installed a new vanity with a solid white cultured marble top in the master bath at our previous house.  It received daily use for over 15 years and held up well, so I think for this application we'll be fine.

 

I was hoping to re-use the Corian top that's on the existing vanity, but its integrated sink is too large to fit into the new vanity.

 

I decided to call the manufacturer and inquire about the sleeve vs. box and was told it's just the packaging.  The "view box" has a window on top to see what's inside and the sleeve is just a plain box.  The "view box" is more expensive by about $25.

 

[vacerator]

Ralph,

If you have already measured and can not modify the vanity to fit your existing Corian top, some times, a nearby fabricator may have a small remnant of quartz, granite, or other solid surface from a big job they can discount to you.
They can cut it out for a lavatory basin of your choice, and finish the edge to your preference for a nominal charge.
Another option may be to fasten a 3/4 inch piece of plywood over the vanity. get a basin, and cut the hole for it, then either side bracket mount, or even glue it down.
Then, you can tile it over with thin set latex modified mortar. The Tech brand guide says so. I've done it. You can use narrow spacers, and you can buy an inexpensive wet saw for under $75, or even use a manual cutter and nippers. Just get extra tile. A few always break on you.
Use latex modified grout, then it is already sealed. Caulk around the faucet and back splash.