Launderess-- You're right; every detergent needn't pack the stain-removing punch of Tide or Wisk. I also notice that, at least in pod format, the "Plus Oxi" version is generally a brand's highest rated formulation at Consumer Reports. This is true of brands like All, Arm & Hammer, and Purex. Ironically, OxiClean's own detergent rates lower than all the above-mentioned.
Update: Interest piqued, I hopped over to Consumer Reports online to check the cleaning score and cost per load of all tested variants of Purex detergents. Quite a spread in costs and cleaning scores. Appears the "Plus Oxi" pak/pod version is the sweet spot in the cleaning/cost axis. Go pods!
Purex Plus Oxi (Pak) Score: 52 (out of 100) Cost: .15 per load
Purex Dirt Lift Action (P) Score: 50 Cost: .15
Purex Plus Oxi (Liquid) Score: 49 Cost: .21
Purex No Sort (L) Score: 47 Cost: .10
Purex Natual Elements (L) Score: 42 Cost: .11
Purex Dirt Lift Action (L) Score: 42 Cost: .07
[this post was last edited: 1/8/2015-08:30]
Update: Interest piqued, I hopped over to Consumer Reports online to check the cleaning score and cost per load of all tested variants of Purex detergents. Quite a spread in costs and cleaning scores. Appears the "Plus Oxi" pak/pod version is the sweet spot in the cleaning/cost axis. Go pods!
Purex Plus Oxi (Pak) Score: 52 (out of 100) Cost: .15 per load
Purex Dirt Lift Action (P) Score: 50 Cost: .15
Purex Plus Oxi (Liquid) Score: 49 Cost: .21
Purex No Sort (L) Score: 47 Cost: .10
Purex Natual Elements (L) Score: 42 Cost: .11
Purex Dirt Lift Action (L) Score: 42 Cost: .07
[this post was last edited: 1/8/2015-08:30]