Question: Steam in a washer, something useful or just marketing hype?

Automatic Washer - The world's coolest Washing Machines, Dryers and Dishwashers

Help Support :

revvinkevin

Well-known member
Platinum Member
Joined
Jan 7, 2007
Messages
5,592
Location
La-La Land
Is there any actual benifit to having steam in a washing machine or is it just marketing hype to sell a more expensive machine?

Yes I can totally see the benifit of having steam in a dryer, but in a washer? It seems like a total and complete waste to me, because I don't see how steam can be of any benifit in cleaning clothes (beyond) those already completely soaked in hot water and detergent.

Please discuss....

Thanks!
Kevin
 
Kevin-I own an LG 9kg steam washer. All I can say is Steam is Awesome! Steam molecules are 1600times smaller than water, so they penetrate deep and loosen stains and kill allergens. I use it all the time on my 2 babies tough food,sick, the other stuff! stained clotheS! It really does work. I am upgrading to the LG 11kg steam when it finally comes out in black and we have moved house. I can be patient with my already awesome LG in the meantime.

The difference between LG steam and others is the LG has a dedicated steam generator. Many other machines merely fill enough to cover the wash element and steam at the end of a cycle.

The Steam refresh for removing odours and creases is a 20minute cycle. I don't iron. I usually wash things according to their label and hang them up immediately and I have no problems. Whilst if something is odour tainted i think it's enough for warrant a wash. But i experiemented by washing my sons coat which had been left in a smokey room and amazingly...it was gone. That was just an experiment and I would generally wash things like that.

So....I am all for steam. I won't buy another machine without it. I have owned ALOT of machines and my LG is probably my favourite.

Darren
 
Thanks for your comments Darren. Question: I assume so, but have you washed the same items (like your childrens clothes) without the steam option to compare or have you always washed them with the steam option?

I guess I don't see how the steam can displace the water already in/on the cloths to make that much of a differene.

I do actually have a steam washer, a TOL Kenmore Elite HE5T, one of the last Whirlpool built machines (see the link below). The main reason I bought it was I got a 65% discount off the price! Anyway, I've only used the steam option a few times and don't see a diffetence. Granted my cloths don't get as dirty as your childrens clothes do.....

FYI, this washer also has a dedicated steam generator.

Kevin

 
Steam For Laundering

Is not a new concept. A Frenchman invented the process late in the 18th or early 19th century for cleaning linen textiles and general laundry work.

Soiled linen/laundry was inserted into a closed chamber where steam was introduced. Such items could have been soaped prior, and the idea was as alluded to above, properties of steam caused textile fibers to open and swell, releasing dirt/soils far easily and without all the rubbing, scrubbing and beating of common to the day laundry methods. Steam also helped santitise laundry and kill vermin.

Benefit of this method was one required vastly less water than the common methods of soaking, boiling and other immersion methods of laundering. After the steamed laundry came out of the chamber, it needed only a quick washing and then on to rinsing.

Today's steam washing machines again build on the theory that using water vapor lessens the need for soaking and with the rather puny amounts of water used in modern front loaders for washing, can give decent results.
 
Hey Kevin

Yea i've done experiments with an without steam. Whilst it is an outstanding machine without the steam, some of the boys foods stains are really difficult to shift. However a good scoop of just Ariel powder and the steam setting and all is clean! I kid you not! As Laundress said; steam allows for great water savings in the main wash. In my LG the action of the steam and the clothes rubbing together being showered by the recirculation jet is a winning combination.

Your kenmore is a stunning machine! How are you getting along with it? Do you have any photo's of it action?

The new LG's here have a smoked door. I'm looking to upgrade to the 11kg steam model next year which has a smoked door and i've inspected them closely in the stores here and don't think it will hinder my view to badly.

Darren
 
Consumer Reports found that cycles adding steam were able to do a better job on stain removal, but added they didn't feel it was enough of a difference to warrant spending more for a steam washer.

As Darren mentioned, LG washers (and dishwashers) have dedicated steam generators and probably do more to remove stains (or food residue) than some other washers, like the Frigidaire I have on order.

I wouldn't have another dishwasher without the steam option, as my LG does a better job on pots/pans with steam than without it. I'm looking forward to the option on my washer, even though I almost went an LG for its dedicated steam generator. I'll be interested to see if steam makes a difference in my Frigidaire washer.

I've also noticed that, at least in dishwashers, Maytag markets their steam feature as effective on glassware, whereas LG markets their more powerful steam option toward stripping grime from pots/pans.
 
Launderess, thank you very much for the info and history! What kind of effect can steam have on a fabric, or the color of the fabric that’s not normally washed in hot water? In other words, can the use of steam cause fading or shrinkage on an item not normally subjected to higher temps during cleaning? Also, should the water temp be hot or can it be warm when using steam?

Darren, thank you! Yes I like the look of this washer too, especially in blue! I’m getting along with it fine and it seems to do a good job of cleaning, but the water lever is pretty skimpy. Don’t get me wrong, I don’t need or want the water level ½ way up the door glass, but I think another 1 to 3 gallons (3.8 L to 11.5 L) per fill would make things better.

I actually don’t like the smoked/tinted plastic over the door glass, for me it obscures the view too much. Oh sure I could sit or stand there with a flashlight or other light, but then I have to hold it and always use it. So what I did was remove the tinted plastic from the door. Yes it’s rather ugly now without it (because of the exposed door frame and hinge), but at least I can see! LOL Also no, I have not really tried taking any photos of it in action, but I suppose I can do that….but I’ll have to put the tinted piece back on first.

So I will have to play with the steam option more and see how things come out!

Eugene, thank you for the info as well. I sounds like it makes sense having steam in a dishwasher too, but I’ve not thought about it. Also I would guess the “steam” models are at the TOL end of things and thus, expensive. Maybe some day. LOL
 
my dream machine is a whirlpool aqua steam washer aparently it can kill bacteria and dustmtes plus steam relaxes fibers so detergent can penitrate deeply i suffer with hay feiver so steem would be xelent for line dryed clothes:)
 
Hey Kevin!-I have not noticed any shrinking or fading caused by steam. I am very picky about fading and have seen no ill effect. Steam can get up to 99degrees (210.2F) at it's peak which it does in stages. I'm asthmatic and I find it particularly helpful on bedding. I wash most clothes at 30degrees (86F) with steam and get excellent results. I have also washed at incoming cold water temperature but I can't use steam on that option. The new 11kg I will be getting has a 20degree (68F) Temperature which you can use steam with.

Honestly. Give it a few goes and i'm sure you'll be pleasantly surprized. I hardly ever need to pretreat anything. Just the correct dosage of Ariel!

Yea I know what your saying about the extra water. I find my LG's medium water level and recirculation jet combined with high speed intermittent spins and up to 5 rinses give great rinsing.

Does your kenmore give you the option of extra rinses? How many does it do as standard? I have read many sources say that the number of rinses is more effective than increasing the water level. I used to be really scepticle of low water levels but they go work! The droppin action and rubbing together with a long rinse time give a good rinse.

Darren
 
Extra rinses.......

Hey Darren,

Yes my Kenmore does offer an extra rinse option and I always use it. I believe there are normally 2 rinses and this just adds a 3rd, but I'll have to check that.

It has another rinse option which is supposed to be for people who have skin sensitivities to detergent. I’m not exactly sure what is does or how it changes the rinses, all I know is it adds more time to the cycle.

Kevin
 
Hey Kevin.

Three rinses have been standard on european Front loaders for a ages. Older ones used to do 4 or 5! But the interm spins were either non existant or short. Some machines here have only 2 which are fairly deep with long interm spins! Every model apart from some hotpoint/indesit machines have an extra rinse option.

Perhaps your sensitive skin rinses are extended rinse phases with a small amount of extra water? The rinse is my favourite part of any cycle. You'll have to let me know if you find out :-)

Darren
 
Rinses

Hi Guys

On my Bosch Maxx 5 the Cotton cycle only has 2 rinses, you do have the option of an extra rinse. The rinse level on the Cotton cycle is very low.

However, you do have a seperate rinse programme where the machine fill with lots of water, half way up the door.

The only good side to my machine is, its very quick at washing. A 60c was on Cotton cycle takes about 58mins.

I have been sorting out some washer stuff and got a brochure on Hoover New Wave machines, anyone wants them, then they can have them.

Paul
 
I have the Maytag 5000 series with steam and the steam cycle does a fantastic job. Now to be honest I couldn't say it was the steam per se that does it, or if it's the longer cycle, or the stepped washing; or a combo of all.

I had a comforter that had the dark yellow stains where it rests under my chin at night. Having previously taken it to the laundry several times a year I could bleach the hell out of it, over suds it with tide and pretreat and the yellow only lightened.

I ran it through one cycle in the Maytag on Heavy Duty and a scoop of Oxi-clean. The stain was gone.
 
Brochures

Hi Rob,

Have they arrived yet?. Been on to Post Office in Royton. They said it takes a couple of days due to the size of envelope.

Let me know when they arrive.

Cheers

Paul
 
@newwave

Re: number of rinses, on my Frigidaire 2140 (a division of Electrolux), there are two rinses (with spins after each rinse) standard on the Heavy, Normal, and Perm Press cycles. (perm press has a brief final spin to minimise wrinkling, but then these fabrics don't absorb water like heavy cottons). You can add a third rinse with the "Extra Rinse" button.

I have limited amounts of German (Henkel) Persil, or Unilever Persil (Persil in UK, Via in Sweden) brought back from European visits. My "perm press" loads are my work clothes, which are "office casual" wrinkle-resistant 100% cotton trousers and shirts from LL Bean. (www.llbean.com). On these, I use my limited supply of European detergent. Such loads dried on a Perm Press cycle (starts out warm, then cools to ambient temperature before end of cycle), if hung up immediately, look as if they have been professionally laundered and ironed. I am frequently asked for the name of my cleaners, with people assuming that these clothes have received professional treatment.

For loads of sturdy cottons, bedding, and towels, I use the one readily available US powder properly formulated ("HE") for front loaders, which is Tide HE. I use 45 ml per full load and I still have a small patch of suds on the door when finished, so it appears that even three rinses aren't enough to rinse away all soap residue. There are never any suds left when using European detergents listed above.

Launderess has posted here (in a different thread) that she suspects the "HE" detergents sold here are not really reformulated. Most likely a suds suppressant is added to avoid oversudsing. FL sales are now about 50% of all new washer sales, but if you consider all the TLs still out there in homes across the country, FLs are far from 50% of all machines IN USE in the country. So with TLs still dominating the market in terms of detergent needs, there is little incentive to rework the formula.

Some of the other brands marked "HE" here, including those sold by Sear (Ultra Plus) and Kirkland, use the "HE" logo on the box but also state that the product is made for use "in all machines", the only difference being they recommend using less in FL than TL. Yeah, right, why use a product that is designed to work in higher-sudsing TLs. Looks like the only reformulation was at the printer's where the box was printed!! I know that some folks here have posted good FL results with Sears Ultra Plus HE powder, but I am reticent when the box states that it is "for all machines".

If Proctor and Gamble ever brought Ariel to the USA, Tide's share of the FL market would be wiped out in weeks or months. One can buy Germal (Henkel) Persil here, but it is sold only via Miele dealers. Miele excercises strict price control on its dealers. Anyone caught discounting prices will lose their license to sell Miele. A medium box of Persil powder runs about $45. Granted, the box will last a long time at 30 ml per load, but that's still a lot of money.

PS: Darren, it's a long, complex story, but in a nutshell, Electrolux licensed a US company to make vacuum cleaners in the USA from between the World Wars. Part of the agreement was that the US vacuum company had exclusive right to the use of the name "Electrolux" in the USA, and on my first trip to Sweden in 1975, I was amazed to discover they made far more than vacuum cleaners. ;) Frigidaire had been a quality brand when it was part of General Motors. GM spun off the division in 1960-70s and it became sort of a ho-hum, also-ran brand. Electrolux bought the company in c.1986 as a way to begin selling their products in the USA by using an old and trusted name, if not as "Electrolux". Later the US vacuum company went out of business and Electrolux bought back the right to use their name in the US. Frigidaire now sells MOL consumer products with Electrolux being more TOL.

To some degree, Frigidaire has become a conduit for the "Europeanisation" of consumer appliances. Example: convection cooking is commonplace in Europe and has been around for decades. In the US, it's been around for years, but usually only on TOL models and brands, in the past found only on "professional" brands like Thermador, Viking, Wolf, etc.

When it was time to give my old BOL range (new with the house in 1988) the heave-ho, my options were limited: behind the range was a gas line plus a 120V outlet. 240V could not be installed without ripping out some walls and cabinets. The architect who designed the house assumed that any upgrade would simply be a better gas range. The controls and lights can operate on 120V power, since gas supplies the cooking heat.

At that time (2001), most convection ranges in USA were electric and needed 240V. Excluding the $5000 professional ranges (Wolf, Viking, Thermador, Dacor, etc.), only four companies in USA offered a gas convection range in their "normal consumer" (non-professional) product lines: KitchenAid, GE, Jenn-Air, and Frigidaire. The first three companies charged an extra $300-400 (above their similar range without convection), while Frigidaire charged $100 extra. The result was a price of $700 instead of $1400-1500 (yes, $1450 for a GE with convection, and we're talking in white or black, not stainless steel). The KA or Jenn-Air might have been worth it, the GE looked clunky and ugly, and the Frigidaire looked sleekest of them all, for 100s less. (note, these were free-standing gas ranges, not the higher-priced slide-in, no-backsplash, counter depth ranges which often cost more than freestanding with similar features).

The range I bought has been upgraded to a model with a fifth burner, higher BTU outputs, and grates that span all the way across the cooking surface. My range has one high output burner, but the current model has two, which are 16K instead of my 12K. Both have a low output simmer burner. It sells with either simple convection (just a fan) or heated convection (wrap-around heating element around the fan) which are priced about $50 apart. The current price is about $800-900, still quite moderate when compared to the competition. One of the best features are the dishwasher-safe grates, so the cooktop still looks brand new. Cast iron grates of course must be cleaned by hand, so porcelain-coated grates that are DW-safe are a big plus.

I think their (Electrolux) philosophy was that advanced features found in Europe need not be restricted to TOL models, and that you'll sell more if you cater to the MOL consumer who wants some upgrades at reasonable cost. Today, nearly all MOL-TOL companies offer gas convection ranges, but back in 2001, only four did.

I think the same philosophy helped Bosch gain DW market share here. I used to think of them as a company whose dishwashers started at $1000 and up. So I was surprised to learn, when my old GE POS needed replacement, that US prices started at $500 (in 2001) and that the Integra Design (controls in door rim, plain metal front) began at $600. Bosch could see that the market for $1000+ dishwashers would always be limited, but that people willing to pay $500-800 were a much larger market segment, one that was pretty much the exclusive province of KitchenAid for years. So if they offered machines with fewer features but the same build/operational quality, they could capture some of KA's market segment, and it appears they have achieved this goal.

PS: the Frigidaire range continues to give excellent service in its ninth year of use. Oven remains properly calibrated. Like any gas range, the heat is vented into the kitchen, but it would be rare to have the oven on for more than two hours, so this rarely becomes an issue. [this post was last edited: 8/17/2010-11:13]
 
lg tromm steam washer

I have used the steam feature on my mom's lg washer with a load of whites. In my dad's GE, he soaks the whites. In my mom's lg tromm, I don't need to soak my whites anymore.

 

Latest posts

Back
Top