Ralph,
I am walking a pretty tight line here. It is sad fact that in the US today, things have become so polarized, that one is pretty much either so or so.
I am most definitely a liberal, closely aligned with the Democrats when it comes to human rights (especially Constitutional Rights like habeas corpus), my right to marry and love the man I care for, a woman's right to decide what to do with her own body, the right of black people to be treated with the same humanity as white people.
But, having grown up in the Rocky Mountain West, not the crime filled violence of big American cities - and living in Western Europe where, although we are armed to the teeth, guns and violence just aren't a problem, I can't do the knee-jerk thing on gun control.
That does not mean I support the NRA, I resigned my life-long membership a long time ago, back when they started looking like the dictionary definition of paranoid.
I think I understand your feelings on the matter, really I try to. I just think it is up to us on the "left" not to fall into the black and white thinking which has let the Republicans win so many folks over to them in the last years.
There is no way in hell you are ever going to get guns out of American society. It's like prohibition. Even if you succeeded in taking them away from people who legally own them, the criminals would still have them. All we can succeed in doing there is in driving otherwise sane people further into the arms of the wing-nut right. And please, even if you only view guns as instruments of crime and evil - for many folks in the West, they are necessary tools. I'm a vegetarian, I don't hunt. But I truly enjoy target shooting.
Of all the issues which separate the east and west coast liberals from the independent and moderate voters in the West and South, this is the one where the folks on the coasts are just going to have to buy a clue - it's a non-starter.
What is much more worth spending time on is the question of why there is so much violent crime in the US. I've said it about a million times, but we are armed to the teeth here and yet we just do not have the problems you have. Sure, the occasional whack job will get a gun and murder people. But it takes us years to equal one bad weekend in Detroit. That is so wrong!
Can we have a dialog - you, me, everyone on this and leave our resentments ("only from my cold, dead hands" "all democrats want to take away our rights" on the one side and "all guns are evil, anybody who carries one is sick" on the other?) I truly don't believe anyone, not even Rex is trying to make you join the NRA.
But if I, one of the most liberal folks on this board can be notional, well, can't we all try a bit?
Huh?
Please?
(Oh, and Rex, I gotta say it - it was the Republicans and not the Democrats who took away your right to habeas corpus. That right was fundamental to what made America free. And your only hope for getting that right back is, hold your nose, the democrats. Just a thought.)