Stove-top Smoker Advice Anyone?

Automatic Washer - The world's coolest Washing Machines, Dryers and Dishwashers

Help Support :

rp2813

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 16, 2006
Messages
18,053
Location
Sannazay
My partner brought home a new stove-top smoker this week. It's a very heavy and nicely hand-crafted piece made by Villa-Ware and carries a 75-year guarantee. It was half price and still wasn't exactly cheap. Has anyone had any experience with one of these? It came with a few recipes and three different types of wood chips. I'm anxious to try it out. Any suggestions or words of wisdom? I'm leaning towards smoked salmon for my first attempt. It has an 8 quart capacity so the pot can be used for other things besides smoking.

Thanks for any advice or further info on this thing.

Ralph
 
Look for a high end BBQ specialty store. They usually carry different kinds of woods such as Apple, Maple, Cherry, etc. They all impart their taste on the meat you are smoking.
Cherry and Apple work well when smoking pork. I read up on smoking a few years ago when we bought our first outdoor smoker.
One of the things smoking books recommended was to smoke a pork butt the first time. They are easy to do and get you used to the idea of smoking meats. Then you can move on to ribs.
We used our smoker a few times and got rid of it. We just didn't use it that often. We found that we actually liked our Webber grill more.
I have never heard of an indoor smoker. Where does the smoke go?
BTW, that smoke salmon sounds great!
 
My advice would be to invest in a very powerful exhaust vent if you don't already have one. Sounds interesting, though; Let us know how your salmon turns out.

I think they recommend starting with a pork butt because you can't kill it no matter what you do. It will be fork tender.
 
First Attempt

Thanks for your input Eugene and Allen. I went looking for my first item to smoke and ended up with a duck breast. Funny story--I was at the local high-end grocery store and when I asked the buther if I could smoke a duck breast he said, "sure you can, but you'll have trouble getting the papers around it!" I guess it's a northern California thing.

Anyway, it was a very simple thing to do, just put a couple of teaspoonsful of chips (they are ground up very small, not like the big chips used in your typical outdoor smoker) in the very bottom, place the drip pan in there, then the rack with duck breast over that and put the lid on and cook for 45 minutes or so. It's a weird set-up but it does work. My partner made a couple of spinach salads with heirloom tomato and sliced up 1/2 the breast for each one and it was a very elegant meal.

The smoker is made of hand-poured aluminum, very heavy gauge and can be used on a campfire as well as on a stove. The lid is heavy enough that very little smoke escapes. I think if there's smoke, you've got the burner going a little too high. We did smell smoke in the house and for the last 10 minutes of cooking time I flicked on the exhaust fan. What I didn't like, and this may be due to the choice of duck as opposed to something less fatty, is that some grease escaped and dripped down the sides of the pot. It's still soaking to try and get that removed. The insides are entirely non-stick and cleaned up easily, but I don't want the exterior to be an unsightly mess so am hoping I can get the whole thing cleaned up later today. This thing is so thick and heavy that it takes forever to cool down after use. I am anxious to try more things as it's an easy way to impart an interesting flavor to meat, poultry or fish.

We still haven't figured out storage yet. It's a large item that may not see regular use as a smoker after the novelty wears off but is an excellent 8-quart pot for other things like a big batch of chili or whatever.

Ralph
 
45 Minutes is pretty quick for a smoker. Usually it takes HOURS to smoke something. I think our first pork butt took 8 hours to smoke. We smoked our ribs for 6 hours. The time it took to smoke was one of the reasons we didn't like to use our smoker.

Here is how we used some chips:

Hickory & Mesquite & Oak - On Beef and Sausages

Cherry, Apple, Apricot, Peach - Poultry and Fish and some sausages

Just make sure the wood is soaked for at least an hour before you use it. From your description of the smoker, it sounds like it would use chips rather than chunks of wood.
 
Eugene, I know--the butcher is definitely boomer age range and I have to say that due to his straight-laced looks I wasn't prepared for that type of reply and it even took me a second or two to realize he wasn't talking butcher paper! I doubt he can joke like that with some of the more uppity types that shop there, but he sized me and my partner up instantly, I guess. I'm pretty sure we used eye drops before venturing out, but my short term memory is shot anymore . . .

Allen, this smoker does work faster on a lot of stuff because it uses a higher heat. The recipe section of the owner's manual leaves quite a bit to the imagination and to be desired, but it does advise that ribs etc will take a couple of hours. Online reviews say these stove-top models don't provide the same quality of smoked flavor due to the fact that there is no convection action since they are completely sealed, but that refers to the type that look like a cake pan with a sliding lid. The VillaWare type that I have is a big pot with a domed lid that supposedly creates the convection action. I was pleased with how the duck turned out and am anxious to try other things. I'll try pork next as they say that's a good one for beginners. Once I know what I'm doing I'll try some salmon.
 
Back
Top