Depends on my mood,
depends on a lot of factors, and one of them is whether or not I have "company!"
Simply put, I am a "soap slut." In the tub/shower right now, I have Dial gold, Coast Original, Dove Fragrance Free, and Walgreens Gentle.
I LIKE the scent of Irish Spring, but only on other guys.
I'm thinking that Lever 2000 is a reissue of Phase III, with a different scent.
Not a big fan of the Caress scents, thogh it does feel nice.
In the bathroom itself, I have Eternity shower gel, Latitude Longitude shower gel, and Claiborne shower gel.
When I find a commodity shower gel I like, it tends to get discontinued or reformulated (essentially the same thing). For a while, Go-Jo Industries (Go-Jo heavy duty hand cleaner, and the originators of Purell) offered a nice one called "Shower Up."
Avon had one for a few years called "Aqua Clean" had a very nice, fresh scent that faded fairly quickly after drying.
Shower gels just don't seem to last as long as bar soaps for me for some unknown reason.
My former dermatologist said that I really should only use Dove or Dove liquid, but I don't really like the scents, except for the newer Dove with green tea and cucumber.
I only use Dawn in the shower when I am cleaning up after certain activities some would consider very exotic.
Lawrence/Maytagbear