Begun, the mayonnaise wars have

Automatic Washer - The world's coolest Washing Machines, Dryers and Dishwashers

Help Support :

supersuds

Well-known member
Platinum Member
Joined
Jul 3, 2007
Messages
1,844
Location
Knoxville, Tenn.
Look out for the mayochup! From the Wall Street Journal:

It’s mayhem in the mayonnaise aisle.

Hellmann’s maker Unilever and Kraft Heinz Co., which owns Miracle Whip, are cutting prices and slinging out new concoctions as they battle changing eating habits, a dizzying array of new competitors and each other.

The two, which together account for more than 80% of U.S. mayonnaise sales, are duking it out because they are at risk of losing shelf space to faster-growing rivals.

U.S. sales of mayonnaise fell 6.7% between 2012 and 2017, according to Euromonitor. Small mayonnaise brands, though, which made up just 3.2% of the market six years ago, have almost doubled their share and last year made up 6.1%.

****

Miracle Whip and Kraft Mayo, Kraft Heinz’s other big mayonnaise brand, have been squeezed between less-costly offerings on one end, and Hellmann’s and other premium brands on the other. Miracle Whip—which doesn’t call itself “mayonnaise” because its oil content doesn’t match food regulators’ definition—lost almost 1 percentage point of U.S. market share between 2015 and 2017. It and Kraft Mayo have just over 30% of the market, according to Euromonitor.

Ms. Healy said Kraft Heinz is engaged in a mayo push, last month launching a new brand—Heinz Mayo—that uses simple ingredients and cage-free eggs. The company also is developing a mayonnaise-ketchup combination that it is calling “mayochup.”

Hellmann’s, called Best Foods west of the Rockies, has raced ahead. While overall mayonnaise sales have declined, it boosted its U.S. market share by 3.5 percentage points in the past three years and now has just over 50% of the U.S. market.

Hellmann’s and Kraft Mayo have come out with new flavors and variations, such as avocado-oil mayonnaise and roasted garlic and spicy chipotle flavors. Kraft revamped the Miracle Whip recipe last year, going back to its original ingredients and replacing high fructose corn syrup with sugar. “It was a huge investment for us,” said Eduardo Luz, president of Kraft Heinz’s U.S. grocery business.

 
I purchase Dukes, now that it is available here in the North. My Great Aunt Maxine, who lived in League City Texas used it, and when we would visit, and I loved it! Mom used Miracle Whip back in the 1960's, and even as a child, I thought that product was far too sweet. So we used Hellmanns until Dukes came available here. Dukes is really good! I love the slight vinegar flavour. I noticed Dukes are now offering a lite version. Has anyone tried it?
 
I buy the Burman's brand from ALDI, scoop it into the Hellman's jar, no one knows the difference....

same goes for peanut butter, cereal, coffee.....

heck, you could refill the water bottles from the tap....kids still drink it

its like taking the Pepsi Challenge, and choosing Jif!

besides, everyone knows, free range chicken eggs cost more, and taste a WHOLE lot different than caged ones....
 
Miracle Whip = Blegh! Too sweet and texture is like some sort of gel!. I much prefer Mayonnaise of any brand, not too picky. Even store brand "salad dressing" is better than Miracle whip.
 
HATE mayo, will not use it, or have it in the house.  Never have, never will.  Miracle Whip all the way.  Mayo is thick and slimy tasting to me. Like the bite of Miracle Whip.  (I will admit it was better before they tweaked the formula, but still miles ahead of mayo...)
 
Heinz mayo was briefly in stores here a few years ago, then disappeared.  It was soupy compared to Best Foods, which is the brand Dave insists on. 

 

I wonder if this new Heinz they're pushing is any different.
 
Oh, I've used many different brands over the years. Back in the day there too many to choose from in the Atlanta area. Everyone I knew used Blue Plate or Kraft when I was young. So I got used to those. Later on Duke's came into the market. Nonetheless, there was a certain attitude that "if your heart is in Dixie" you ate Blue Plate mayonnaise, drank Coca-Cola, and flew on Delta Air Lines. A deep-south thang.

My take-away from the Heinz factory tour is that the Heinz products are beyond surgically clean. After that tour, I know what a clean factory is supposed to be like. So I am sure their product is very good. There is NO OTHER ketchup as far as I am concerned, and I can't think of a Heinz product I ever disliked.

Making my own mayonnaise is easy, so I do that if I know I will use it all up right away. Otherwise, I naturally reach for the Blue Plate or the nearly identical Duke's. They are both not so much "creamy" as they are full-bodied. I prefer those brands over all others.

Miracle Whip is not even a contender.
 
I've been buying Duke's for the past couple years, and like it really well. Previous to that I used Heinz for a while, and found it to be very suitable also. I don't know why the article would claim it to be new, as it's been around for a long time. Maybe they have a new formula for it, as they do for the Heinz Tarter Sauce - it was improved greatly a few months ago. I used Hellman's for many years before, as that was what my mom bought after always getting Miracle Whip when I was a kid.

My cousin Lisha's husband Billy will only eat Blue Plate mayo, and goes through a gallon jar every month. When they lived in Louisville, KY, they would buy a case of it when visiting Mississippi. I thought it was only sold in the South, but checking Reily Foods website, I see it is now sold in Wal-Mart in the Cincinnati area. May get a jar soon.
 
You either like it or you don't.

Personally, I prefer the home-made stuff. It's not hard to do, once you master patience.

As to Miracle Whip: It's so sweet it works really well in some fruit salads. But otherwise?

No.*****Way.
 
Best Foods when only the best will do! Its what I’ve used all my life it is consistently good and never disappoints. If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it. I’ve tried Kraft in the past, when the store was out of Best Foods and it wasn’t bad, but its not Best Foods. It’s worth the price and I always have two extra jars on hand as backup, so I never again have to settle for something else in a pinch.

Eddie
 
Here are the few things that I put mayonnaise on:

Yes, because it does make an interesting "secret sauce" with ketchup (though often, I think you can get away with tartar sauce,--which most "secret sauces do--and that only adds pickles, and why just for sea food?!), and I guess you need it as a "foundation" for horseradish & you sometimes need to tame it...

Of which I (due in part for it to be the entire word, "Mayonnaise", not just (because they don't know how to spell?) MAYO!) am definitely a HELLMAN'S Guy!!!!

Now, I believe Hellman's does put a chicken recipe on back of their jars, (which I made a couple times) but I somehow I cannot find, from either time, the pictures of...

-- Dave

daveamkrayoguy-2018052116260801565_1.jpg

daveamkrayoguy-2018052116260801565_2.jpg

daveamkrayoguy-2018052116260801565_3.jpg
 
Back
Top