Front vs Top load
Hi Pierre.
To argue your points a bit:
• Removes more dirt on average in a normal cycle front load washer.
Well, I guess that depends on the load, but front loaders are better at getting sand out of clothes than a top loader, at least in my experience. I've also experienced slower turnover in a top loader than in a front loader.
• Met generally less time to complete a normal cycle that front-loading washer.
Depends on the cycle. The Speed Queen / Huebsch washers have a 44 minute wash cycle. (For regular, I think the Perm. Press cycle may be 5 minutes shorter) I have some friends which have an LG, if you set it on Sanitize with heavy soil, the entire cycle takes about 2.5 hours. (Yikes!)
• Is generally less noise than a front-loading washer.
Disagree with you there. One of the reasons why a top loader is quieter is because the spin isn't as fast. I believe most modern top loaders spin around 600-700 RPM, whereas the front loaders I saw do anywhere between 1000-1400 RPM. So, that's not a fair comparison. I have found that front-loaders are a little noisier when washing the clothes, but that's a good thing. The more splashing, sloshing and splooshing sounds, the more water is moving and thereby the more cleaning it's doing. Quietness has never really been a measure of cleaning performance for me. The big concern I think is spinning and it's not a fair comparison.
Asko makes a washer which spins the clothes at 2000 RPM. I would bet money that there wouldn't be a room in the house you wouldn't hear that. No need for that though. After all, dryers are designed to dry clothes.
• is more ergonomic, due primarily to the position of openness and lack of clean seal.
I agree that without pedestals, you have to stoop down to load and empty clothes. Pedestals fix that. A lot of front loaders these days come with the pedestals included or are extra for a rather modest cost.
I also agree that front loaders don't need a door seal. What I'm seeing though in European made washers is that the seal is actually on the door itself rather than between the door opening and the tub. I hope that more washer manufacturers finally realize this is the way to go and makes the machines much more hygenic.
I can see though how that is a considerable advantage.
Now, on the downside, for top loading washers to give you a good wash with lots of good turnover, you really need to think about your water bill. Do you mind living with the idea that your top loader uses 180 litres per wash instead of 50-something litres a front loader would use? If not, then yeah, go for it.
IMHO, you sound really eager to get rid of your current set and buy something else which you may like a lot better. What's stopping you?
Buy a Speed Queen / Huebsch set... you'll be happy with it. Top or front load!