Rebeccah, the washer at the very top of this thread at first glance looks like your machine, however there are significant differences. On that machihne, notice it has normal cycle. This cycle starts out with fast agitation at the 10 minute mark and shifts to slow agitation at the 6 minute mark. Spins are normal spin speed and rinse agitatoin is also slow/gentle. Perm Press also starts out with fast agitation at the 10 minute mark and shifts to gentle at the 6 minute mark. Spin speeds and rinse agitation are also gentle on this cycle. heavy duty is like your cotton/sturdy cycle--fast agitation and fast spin speeds. The slow agitatin/fast spin speed conbimatnion was deeemed (Normal) fabrics--this was Sears' stupid way of getting around the customers like you & I who had this type of tearing problem, and there were many.