I teach
students from Israel, Palestinians, Iran and various Arabian countries.
I have had good and bad students from each group, friendly and unfriendly students.
But never, ever, has an Israeli threatened to kill me or another student.
No doubt there has been injustice and unfairness in dealing with the Palestinians.
But we need to be very clear about the history, the post WWII United Nations decisions and, finally, the question of who attacked whom. It is very easy to be critical of Israel - a democracy and an open state.
But speaking as a gay man, speaking as someone who is routinely considered to be an 'American' by foreign students (I have an American English accent), the violence and hatred shown towards me and towards all open homosexuals by the Islamic world makes me doubt their peaceful intentions.
I don't want to start a flame war here, but I suspect there is a strong anti-Jewish sentiment behind the knee-jerk sympathy so many people express for the Palestinians. When they start treating gays and women as human beings, start holding democratic elections and stop attacking, resp. cease their terrorist activities, then I will be more than happy to change my opinion of them.
Sure, Israel has made some serious mistakes. For me, it's personal. I was in Frankfurt in 1987, at the airport. I have had Palestinians try to kill me, the worst I have suffered at the hands of the Jews was being beaten at Chess by Danny Kelmann in seventh grade. Come live in Europe for awhile and you will find out just exactly how 'oppressed' and 'noble' the Islamic world really is...not.
students from Israel, Palestinians, Iran and various Arabian countries.
I have had good and bad students from each group, friendly and unfriendly students.
But never, ever, has an Israeli threatened to kill me or another student.
No doubt there has been injustice and unfairness in dealing with the Palestinians.
But we need to be very clear about the history, the post WWII United Nations decisions and, finally, the question of who attacked whom. It is very easy to be critical of Israel - a democracy and an open state.
But speaking as a gay man, speaking as someone who is routinely considered to be an 'American' by foreign students (I have an American English accent), the violence and hatred shown towards me and towards all open homosexuals by the Islamic world makes me doubt their peaceful intentions.
I don't want to start a flame war here, but I suspect there is a strong anti-Jewish sentiment behind the knee-jerk sympathy so many people express for the Palestinians. When they start treating gays and women as human beings, start holding democratic elections and stop attacking, resp. cease their terrorist activities, then I will be more than happy to change my opinion of them.
Sure, Israel has made some serious mistakes. For me, it's personal. I was in Frankfurt in 1987, at the airport. I have had Palestinians try to kill me, the worst I have suffered at the hands of the Jews was being beaten at Chess by Danny Kelmann in seventh grade. Come live in Europe for awhile and you will find out just exactly how 'oppressed' and 'noble' the Islamic world really is...not.