Whirlpool Accuses Samsung & LG Of Dumping Washers

Automatic Washer - The world's coolest Washing Machines, Dryers and Dishwashers

Help Support :

thanks for the info

qualin and all of you... why I come here.
I hope to learn more about Speed Queen... my last memory of them was when they were usually the laundry set of choice being given away on "Queen For A Day"... ooooh now I've REALLY dated myself!
 
It's a major pull-to-start issue for me, I lost a 6-figure career to this process and watched it happen from the inside. I was engineering integrity engineer for Dell, at the time the Maytag of the industry. I'm still using a 1998 Dell, they were bulletproof and the service comprehensive.

But in 2001 the MBAs got ahold of Dell and took the guts out. Laid off everybody who knew anything and gave a shatner (me and everyone I knew). Now they're the WCI of computers and service consists mostly of "accidentally" hanging up on customers so they'll give up and go away.

They threw all their engineering onto Foxconn (Taiwan) which actually does all their work (that which actually gets done*) in China. Where the factories had to install nets around their buildings to keep employees from comitting suicide off the roof. Foxconn also has contract facilities in Mexico, where employees have set fire to the plant. Three times.

* When it comes to engineering integrity, Dell asks Foxconn "did you test it, does it work?" and Foxconn says "sure it does". But actually testing it would cost them $3 a week wages. No "self respecting" Taiwanese businessman is going to pass up an opportunity to stuff $3 in his pocket. So they lie. And Dell buys it, even knowing otherwise.

What were we saying about ethics?
 
To Firedome and Arbilab

Firedome: http://www.speedqueen.com .. Everything you could ever want to know. They also have a facebook channel as well.

To Arbilab:

I've worked in the IT industry for close to 21 years, so I can sympathize with you.

> I was engineering integrity engineer for Dell,

I remember back in the early 2000's, a Chinese capacitor manufacturer stole a electrolyte formulation from a Japanese company, but they left out a very critical component of the formulation which would have stopped Hydrogen from building up in the capacitors.

This Chinese company underbid everyone and sold massive amounts of these defective capacitors to everyone. They were in EVERYTHING... but most noticeably, I saw them in Dell servers.

I have seen ENTIRE RACKS of Dell servers fail because of these bad capacitors. Dell basically told me to !@#$% off because I was a small time customer. I swore that the only Dell servers I'd ever buy from that point on would be corporate non-mission critical budget-critical machines. (ie. You get what you pay for. If the server blows up, who cares, just replace it.)

I think Dell learned a very expensive lesson from this.

> I'm still using a 1998 Dell, they were bulletproof and the service comprehensive.

The Dells my company uses now have been pretty rock solid for the most part. They're all late 2000's vintage (The oldest one being from 2006) and they've had absolutely remarkable uptime. Their service support on the other hand.... well, don't get me started.

> But in 2001 the MBAs got ahold of Dell and took the guts out.

That probably explains the switch to the lowest bidder when it came to the parts for their machines and probably the outsourcing too. I don't have anything against Indians, but outsourcing has cost them a lot more than they realize.

>Now they're the WCI of computers and service consists mostly of "accidentally"
>hanging up on customers so they'll give up and go away.

... and that's assuming that you don't manage to actually speak with someone with an extremely heavy Punjabi accident who barely understands the issue. I think outsourcing their customer service was one of the worst business decisions they ever made.. but I'm glad to hear they reversed their stand on it.

> install nets around their buildings to keep employees from comitting suicide off

I read about that. The sad part is, even if Dell knew to take very strict measures with Foxconn and say things like, "No employee works more than 8 hours a day", etc, etc... The factory owners and managers will find ways around that.. They will fudge the timeclocks, etc.. When the ethics don't exist, no amount of honesty can be forced upon people.

> where employees have set fire to the plant. Three times.

Wow. They must really hate their jobs to do that. At least in Mexico, they can unionize. I think it is certainly sad that Unions haven't stood up for these people. It's a huge political battle too. They still don't have rules there which protect Unions... at least, not yet.

> Dell asks Foxconn "did you test it, does it work?" and Foxconn says "sure it
> does".

Heh.. "We sold it to you and the customer didn't return it. Isn't that enough?"

> What were we saying about ethics?

You drive home some very good points. I only wonder what it would take to put a complete and total stop to this. Legislation? Huge import tariffs?
 
A New Year

Funny,

I had company over for New Year's Day and they took turns filing through the laundry room to look at my shiny Speed Queen's. All but one of my guests didn't know who Speed Queen was and the one commented that they went out of business year's ago.

Unless you get out and do your research, you wont know anything about Speed Queen.

Additionally, nobody knew anything about Miele and couldn't pronounce it either.

Malcolm
 
I agree that education has a large leading factor into it.

It certainly is easy for a consumer to walk into an appliance shop or worse, a big box hardware store and just buy the first thing the salesman tells them to.

Malcolm, I'm glad to hear that you are proud of your laundry set. Showing off my washer/dryer to guests isn't something I would normally do. :) (I did once think about buying the Imperial set, but the washer sells for $2700 here. Strangely enough, the dryer is only $100 more. I didn't really see the advantage of spending the extra $900 to get stainless steel over white cabinets.)

If Alliance just got out there and put up a few TV ads that said, "We're not out of business!!! Buy our stuff!", I'm sure that would change a few minds quickly. Hanging out on Facebook and having year old videos on youtube doesn't really cut it IMHO. It helps, but it's not enough.
 
nobody knew anything about Miele and couldn't pronounce

I'm stunned....

 

I reckon that I could show 100 random people walking in the street the Miele brand (red logo and correct font) and on a bad day, 60-70% would recognise the brand and could tell me at least 2 products they make....

 

But then, they have sold in our market for well over 30 years now and with 95% of our population concentrated in major cities (compared to 31% USA), maybe we've had more promotional exposure......
 
Shame I didn't see this thread earlier :(

I just thought exactly about this.
Since my visit to a factory, I got in touch with so many people who are "in the industry" completely independent from any manufacturer. People both from Serbia and Italy (mostly ones who aren't nececarily connected to the manufacturer in who's factory I went).

I noticed that engineers in the industry that are there for a lot of years, literally laugh at Samsung or LG machines. They simply don't want to accept them as genuine washing machine producers, especially older ones (50+ years old) which talk about them with certain level of hate like:
"Manufacturers of both washers and detergents, worked throught decades (long before Samsung even existed), on less suds, anti-suds systems etc, and NOW we are seing unbelivable - something that "we've been fighting with" for decades, we see as EXCLUSIVE option, which makes and fills drum to the top with it. They just look at them as ridiculous things, that "You have to be blind to not-see inexperience of their engineers". That's what they said, I still don't have an oppineon about that, but for now, I respect what those people said. So I guess if I asked them about this, I thing they'd deffinatley be on WP's side

Sadly, all the big talk ends up on costumers, and people who sell all those products (which are here in 90% completely un-educated, and non-interested, just waiting for payment for on their account to show up) who are both PIGS and DONKEYS (gentle words used), which care only about money, and find 1000s of reasons to convince you that they are right when they don't even care neither about washing, brand(name), if it comes from their country or not, quality, some of them even comment "ah we don't need to be that clean, we aren't a hospital" etc
Before I saw that with my eyes, and heared it with my ears, I thought such people don't exist on planet Earth - but it seems I was very wrong :(

Dex
 
Miele in USA

Maybe there's little exposure to Miele in the USA because it is only a 'snob appeal' brand?

You know, 'if you have to advertise, you aren't snobby enough'?

Or maybe Americans just aren't domestic?
 
my 2 cents in this post

Here is my 2 cents in this post i think for 1 thing its the fact that its competition for 1 thing and second i have a 2004 duet whirlpool washer dryer set that are 8 years old and they are still workingand in fall 2012 it will be the 9 year i have this generation 1 duet set and they are still working and second the main reason brands like miele washers are unkown to consumers is because the price must be pretty high or the capecety of the washer do not fit familys of todays needs and as for huebesh speed queen in canada and the us if speed queen wents to be known in the consumers market they should realse tv commercials and advertise in magazines or have a set hook up and saying to the consumers try us in store and if you love or cleaning power buy us for your family needs well this is my 2 cent in this post.
 
Miele

While vastly more popular than say ten years ago still is a niche brand in the USA and will remain so far as one can see.

With a limited distribution network and all parts having to be imported from Germany (other than what is already in stock at the main warehouse in New Jersey), service work in particular DIY is difficult. If one lives near a main (upscale) urban area then finding a dealer and or repairman is likely to be eaiser than other parts of the United States.

In Europe one can walk into any number of supply houses or find on the Internet parts for Miele appliances. There is also a very large network of service personnel for repair work not just those directly from Miele. This helps because the world round Miele's call out charges are dear.

When the offerings of front loading washing machines were few in the USA Miele made sense, but with the American market virtually moving towards all front loaders there are other obvious and less expensive choices.

Unlike Asko and Bosch Miele refuses to build a plant in North America so everything sold here must incur extra costs for duty, tranport and other fees.
 
To Launderess and nrones

I agree with you.

I did find it frustrating that if I did want to consider Asko or Miele, I'd have to put up with poor service, if I needed it. In theory, if a machine is supposed to be extremely reliable, why would I need it?

It's a hard sell to someone to say, "Oh yeah, this machine costs $1000 more but does the same things and has crappier service and support."

I really hate the designation of "Snob Brand".. because these are legitimate companies which make a legitimate product which do a legitimate thing very well and reliably enough. It's just that they come from Europe that gives them a snob appeal.

It's kind of like buying a Lamborghini because you want to get to work faster... Is it a snob brand? Kinda.. Yes, they're expensive cars but look what they'll do. I seriously doubt I'd be driving to work at 300 km/h in one though. :)

To Nrones:

The problem with engineers thinking they're better than everyone else, is that as soon as you stop paying attention to #2, you will become #2. Overconfidence and ignorance can destroy a company.

Look at Hyundai.. Back in the 1980's, they used to be a joke here in Canada. Cars were coming off the line with bent frames and all kinds of defects. They were known for rusting like nobodies business and didn't last all that long as a result.

Now, they build cars which are considerably reliable, dependable and feature laden. They are a serious competitor to domestic brands here. GM, Ford and Mopar (Chrysler) underestimated them and look at what happened.

Hyundai ate their lunch, that's what!

In a lot of ways, these industries parallel each other.

I think Samsung and LG are becoming serious competitors to American brands. Very serious competitors. If the domestic manufacturers don't smarten up soon and smell the bacon, they will have their lunch eaten for them quicker than they can blink and by then it'll be too late.
 
My toughts on this

this is my toughts but me i think that they are trying to make some serious compition to whirlpool and my tought is that sure its nice to pay a higher price but the problem is that if service is needed and they do not have in store or the repair truck the needed part for repair in the case of lg or samsung where do they have to order the part if they have to order the part from there european factory how many days will it take before the part arrives in the repair shop and the teck comes to install the new part unless they pay for 24 hours rush delevery to have the part the next day but thats not counting custom that may went to open the package and check the content. If i had to have a service repair done on my washer and the service tech would tell me after evaluating that the cost of the repair woould cost the price of a new washer i would buy a maytag maxima washer dryer set or another whirlpool duet set because in the near future i went to have the dryer stack on top of the washer.
 
Samsung

Qualin,
How many years took Hyndai to "eat lunch"? I have a feeling that all this with Samsung and LG is going too fast. I mean just 4 years ago, Samsung machines were a laugh, that costed 150-180 euros (image) (cheapest on the market), with programmes not resulting to a good wash (frend from school had it, and complained), also lifetime was measured in months. All that lead into fail of 3 representative Samsung offices in Serbia.
Then all of the sudden, Samsung released new (better) products, with so much confidence. I have no experience with their machines, but if they are doing exact same story as they did with mobile phones - that is NO thanks for me.

To be precise - I was Ericsson (SonyEricsson later) user since my first phone. 4-5 years ago I remember me and my friend's Sony Ericssons falling on the floor 10000times, it got only scratchs, sometimes it would strongly land on the floor - again beautiful camera pictures and everything, just got scratches, while my friend's (more of them) who had Samsungs, for the same had dead displays, speakers, flat cable breaking etc.
Years passed, Samsung "built-up" it's reputation, and after 4 SE's I bought a Samsung (newest model then), and just after few months - it got worn out, flimsy, speaker broke down, and for the end it slammed on the floor, and had to visit service because of that. While my friend stuck to SE, who's phone is like new.

This is why I have less confidence in Samsung products. I gave them 1 shot on their "reputation", and they disappointed me as much as they could.
Now when I look at the image, they don't look as bad as they actually were

nrones++1-11-2012-10-19-39.jpg.png
 
To Nrones

Hey, thanks for the replies everyone.

Maybe there may be a day where there will only be three or four washer/dryer manufacturers left. I'm not looking forward to it.
 
There may be a day

I think it is already reality in someway..

Italian market would be great example:
Rex, Zanussi, Zoppas, AEG = Electrolux
Candy, Hoover, Zerowatt, Iberna, Rosiers = Candy
Indesit, Hotpoint, Ariston, Scholtes = Indesit
Bosch, Siemens, Neff, Gaggenau = BSH
There is more, of course, but these are 4 biggest examples.

So we have 17 names, and 4 manufacturers...

Not to mention fact, that even between those 4 is not rare to see same parts, for example Drain pump is made by independent pump company called Askoll, used in Indesit, Candy, and Electrolux machines, so we have the same drain pump for 13 brands on the market out there.

But isn't it similar in America too? Frigilux, Maypool etc?

Dex
 
One Can Sum Up State Of USA Appliance Market In A Word

Maytag.

When that famous brand was up for grabs aside from the Chinese the other other major interested party was a venture capital company. The former was simply unacceptable to many in government and the American population in general. Whilst the latter most certainly would have meant the Maytag corporation's assets would have been raped and pillaged then what was left of the corpse left to twist in the wind. With only those options on the floor Whirlpool was allowed to become a behemoth by gobbling up it's historical rival.

Strange that Whirlpool should be wailing and moaning about Asian competition. At the time they were seeking government approval of their purchase of Maytag, Whirlpool clearly stated that because of imports from China, Korea and other countries they would *not* become a monopoly and violate anti-trust laws.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top