A/C gone bad

Automatic Washer - The world's coolest Washing Machines, Dryers and Dishwashers

Help Support :

The only way I would go with mini splits is if it was an older home that I couldn't feasibly get ductwork in without ripping too much of it apart, or if I had a specific area that needed cooling. My neighbor built a room addition with radiant floor heat and used a mini split for cooling, which made the most sense.
Those systems can quickly reach or exceed the cost of a conventional forced air system, especially if you're using higher quality brands like Mitsubishi Mr Slim. Conventional forced air if designed properly is more discrete, costs the same or less than mini splits, and has less electronics to fail on the equipment.

Interestingly, I see a trend of people ripping out hot water or steam heating systems and putting in mini split heat pumps on the east coast. Those people probably wonder why their house suddenly feels draftier after doing that...
 
Still cooling. Forecast predicts at least one day this week hitting high of 80. HHave my heat pump t-stat set for auto switch between cooling and heating.

Growing up, not uncommon to run A/C on Thanksgiving and sometimes Christmas, depending upojn cooking done s well as guests.
 
#39

I can't help but wonder what would possess people to spend that kind of time, energy, & money to swap out an existing system for mini split heat pumps. What would the point be? Or what would the sales line be?

One thing I've seen done about the one unit for two floors problem is to extend the return ducts from the floor of the first floor to the ceiling of the second floor. This way the hottest air is drawn into the system for cooling. I'm talking about a typical 60's development house with a warm air system that has had an a/c unit slapped in with no modification to the ducts.
 
The most common scenario is the boiler needs replacing and:

1. They want central air.

2. They don't want to pay for a new boiler AND central air.

3. They want to cut fuel costs by switching away from oil (if applicable).

4. They don't want to rip apart the house/build soffits for ductwork.

5. They don't like how much room the radiators take up in every room.

...So out go the radiators and in go the mini splits.

If they have the room to run ductwork then switch "mini split" to "forced air".

I talked to a friend of my sisters not that long ago that just bought a house a half mile away from mine that was built around 1906, it was a higher end house for it's time so it had radiators instead of the usual gravity warm air (that was more prevalent in this part of the suburbs back in those days due to cost economics). The radiators were ripped out sometime in the 70s for forced air and central AC.
 
A Mini can go just about ANYWHERE.  All that is needed is a 3" to 4" hole through an outside wall.

 

No ductwork, no window, no basement, no attic necessary.  If you have ductwork or radiator pipes you can just abandon them.  Lots of chimneys and fireplaces have been abandoned over the years.

 

I would not ever do a duct system again because:

1.) they need to be woven through a house and often require a lot of cutting

2.) unless you have zoning there is limited control of temperature in each room

3.) noise follows the ducting thru-out the home

4.) dirt and mold growth inside that you can't reach to clean

5.) not efficient compared to mini

 

This guy even installed it in his RV.  It's way better than those noisy roof top things.

 



 

 

 
 
 
The selected contractor said the choice system won't be in-stock until end of December-ish.  They're checking on an alternate brand (likely the same) ... so either I wait or opt for a lesser choice.
 
#43-46

Thanks all, for the info. I guess which way you go depends on how much what you presently have bothers you/is deficient in some way. Then again, I'm probably not part of the targetted demographic group because SHINY-SHINY-NEW-NEW by itself doesn't appeal to me.

I do have one question about using mini-splits for heating. I think all the ones I've seen have been mounted on a wall up by the ceiling. Great for a/c but even if the heat output is adequate doesn't that leave the floor cold and low level drafts more noticeable?
 
I would never use a heat pump because of the noise issue. Even though a mini is far quieter than an outdated central air unit, it still makes noise. There is nothing that makes a chilly Fall or Winter day or night colder than having a stupid fan running.... or any avoidable mind numbing noise.

Baseboard heaters are simple, affordable, zone-able, 100% efficient, and of course (nearly) silent. When the technology comes out for silent Air conditioning, it will no doubt be my new favorite. Perhaps a large version of a thermo-electric refrigerator.

Also, like central air units, mini-splits THAT HAVE the heat pump option, are more complicated as they have a reversing compressor and other tech. When doing a search for a mini always specify COLD ONLY and the voltage desired as most minis are made as heat pumps and to operate at 220v.

bradfordwhite-2021111918284808810_1.png
 
Jim

I don't know that you could use a heat pump of any kind <span style="text-decoration: underline;">exclusively</span> because you're too far north in New Jersey (Nuu-Joy-zee).

 

------

 

The big thing many people overlook when it comes to making our homes comfortable is proper insulation.  The more the better.  Aim for at least an R-60 in the attic and R-30 in the walls and floors.  It's so obvious.  Forget about the minimums set by zoning.  And it benefits us regardless of the season.  It doesn't make noise, doesn't require service, and there's no monthly service costs for insulation.  lol

bradfordwhite-2021111918583203025_1.png
 
You'll have to be more specific Bob.  Are you suggesting baseboard heaters don't work in Rochester NY?  

 

They work anywhere as long as there is electric, they're wired correctly, and the circuits on.  lol 

 

About the only thing that can break is the thermostat.  I've seen that and easily fixed it.  

 

Take your choice of thermostat from basic for $11 to a snazzy smart thermostat for a couple hundred. 

 

Better than trying to figure out a gas furnace with all it's sensors and inefficiencies, and the possibility of a cracked exchanger.  Or starting a wood burning fire and that awful smell , no control of temp, and the filthy wood and dust.  Don't get me started on disgusting oil furnaces.....

bradfordwhite-2021111919070601555_1.png
 
Glenn

"...I need a some ambient noise to sleep."

Oh wow, you ACTUALLY want noise.  Each to their own I guess. 

"heating mode is no more noisy than cooling mode"   Yes, that's another reason I don't do heat pumps.

 It can never be quiet enough by my standards.

--------------

You know you can turn on a video, maybe ASMR, or a rain video, birds chirping, thunder storms, that kind of thing.   Sometimes I need to have quiet drama or comedy playing when go to bed but it has to be sound level balanced, so I guess I understand what your referring to.   But I would not want a fan running or anything like that.



 

 
City traffic

This must be a traffic cam or something.  

By my standards it's awful, and disgusting, and repulsive....

 

To each their own.

 

 

Similar threads

volsboy1
Stans Heating and Air destroyed my heat pump.
Replies
4
Views
5
ken
ken
F
Christmas decorations
Replies
15
Views
16
cuffs054
C
W
Beginning year 4 as a homeowner
2
Replies
32
Views
33
washman
W
H
Market analysis at the begining of 2018
Replies
3
Views
8
DADoES
DADoES
volsboy1
Is Hvac hacks are the normal now.. Advice ??
Replies
0
Views
7
volsboy1
volsboy1

Latest posts

Back
Top