Sam's Club brand Wind Fresh is very good. Sold in a pail, 214 loads. Bought it last spring and it has lasted us nearly a year, often use less than what it called for. Think it does as well as Tide, couldn't tell that much difference.
I used Cheer powder for a long time, it cleaned pretty good but I got tired of running so many rinses, as it is high studding. Towels were a lost cause. Neither detergent has optical fabric brighteners.
Bought a box of Tide With Bleach last week, thought I would try it again after several years. Once I opened it up I realized it had Optical Brighteners in it. Will give it away to a friend of ours, very allergic
to the brighteners, can't be around that. I did run a test load with it to compare to the Wind Fresh and couldn't tell that much difference. Swore off P&G products years ago and I should have stuck to it.
I recommend Wind Fresh.

I used Cheer powder for a long time, it cleaned pretty good but I got tired of running so many rinses, as it is high studding. Towels were a lost cause. Neither detergent has optical fabric brighteners.
Bought a box of Tide With Bleach last week, thought I would try it again after several years. Once I opened it up I realized it had Optical Brighteners in it. Will give it away to a friend of ours, very allergic
to the brighteners, can't be around that. I did run a test load with it to compare to the Wind Fresh and couldn't tell that much difference. Swore off P&G products years ago and I should have stuck to it.
I recommend Wind Fresh.
