I would have chosen water level control over color...
I have been happy with my older model Maytag mvwp575gw, which is over six years old now. Only replaced the inexpensive agit dogs (a few dollars when purchased from eBay). With this in mind and given the limited availability of Speed Queen and prices in some areas (some in my area sell above MSRP), I tend to think most in all income brackets would have chosen water level control over color. Not sure why they couldn't have both but...
My appliances don't have to be the same brand, but I do prefer the same color. It's going to be a lot harder to match a black one. But a different color would bother me a LOT more. Most washers and dryers are in their own room or in a closet. Some like mine could be in a room also used as an entrance, but still I doubt that's the case in higher end homes where SQ seems to market to. I am guessing they were getting a few more sales from people like me but now will lose them for decisions like this. Here's why.
I do think you will get more years out of the SQ. If there is enough difference in price, that doesn't really matter in the end to me. I hate it for the landfills, but with the Maytag now with water level control (my ONLY real complaint) I'm not really spending any more money for the actual years of use based on what *I* would pay for those models where I live. It's also a lot easier to find the Maytag model with more choices for how to pay and delivery options.
How many gallons of water does the Maytag mvwp586 use to wash its different size loads now?
The Speed Queen's Normal Eco uses 13 gallons and 16 gallons with deep fill.
Other cycles uses 14.5, 16, or 19 depending on cycle chosen and if deep fill is selected.
I don't know, but doesn't seem to be the best marketing decision on SQ's part. They could have at least thrown in a water level control...
As for me...I already have the SQ TC5 that I purchased when I needed a new dryer. I just assumed the MT would break like everyone says it would, but it's still washing full loads, and I'm using the TC5 for half loads.
Yep, I still have that third washer too.
My plan is to use the Magic Chef until it breaks for even smaller loads since I already have it and then replace it with something portable from Laundry Alternatives. At some point, I will just have one full-size washer and one portable. Sometimes, certain things just need to have their own load OR I will just have to use more water than necessary for those loads. Not my first choice, but that's what the end result of the gov. well intentioned but not well researched eco regulations are.