"Four Kitchen Gadgets You Shouldn't Buy"

Automatic Washer - The world's coolest Washing Machines, Dryers and Dishwashers

Help Support :

sudsmaster

Well-known member
Platinum Member
Joined
Dec 23, 2004
Messages
15,034
Location
SF Bay Area, California
Well, the author is entitled to her opinion, like anyone.

Good buys vs. gadget overload

"A lot of times, those appliances that are supposed to make life easier do just the opposite," says Ann Sullivan, author of Uncluttering Your Space, and owner of a New York City based company specializing in home organizing. "Keeping too many devices can cost you more than just space, because you'll pay for it in the time it takes to clean them and move them around again and again."

The least-wanted list

As Sullivan sorts through kitchens, she sees the same unused appliances popping up. Here are her top space offenders.

1) Juicer. "Lots of people add juicers to their wedding registry," Sullivan says. "But less than 10% of my clients use them at all after the first month."
2) Bread maker. "Maybe you catch a whiff of fresh-baked bread while at someone's house and think it's a good idea," Sullivan says. "But often you can count the number of times a bread maker is used on one hand."
3) Countertop grill. "I've seen people who have small, medium, and large countertop grills," Sullivan says. "These can be useful, but you don't need three, and they shouldn't be on the counter."
4) Electric can opener. "Instead of having an electric can opener that takes up space on the counter, I recommend having a solid, handheld opener that you can stow in a drawer," she says.

Personal disclosure: I own one of each of the following items. Of these, I still use the electric can opener(s). The countertop grill has gone into unused storage. The juicer and the bread maker still sit on a counter in my kitchen, but I haven't used either much in the past year or two. But this doesn't mean that I won't be using either in the future if the need arises.

Counter top grills? Well, I think it was quite a fad, popularized by George Foreman. But realistically one can get equally good results from a good frying pan, and then draining off the excess fat as needed before serving.

I strongly disagree with the opinion expressed on electric can openers. These generally do a better job at opening cans than the hand held versions. I have two electric versions: one that does the traditional cut through the top of the lid, and another that does the more modern cut through the side of the lid. Each has its place. The side lid cutting is cleaner, resulting in less spillage, generally, and works well for stuff like cat food where it leave a lid one can put back on the can to store the unused portion in the fridge overnight. But not all cans can be opened with the side-cutting action. I also have handheld versions of each, because large (#10) cans generally don't fit or are too heavy for the electric versions. And of course they will work in a power outage.

Like most other guys, I like gadgets and it doesn't bother me if a small appliance sits unused in the kitchen for months or has to be moved into storage. I could stand to reduce the kitchen clutter, however, and the juicer is likely to be moved into storage during the next clean-up.

 
I agree with these, we have all except for the countertop grill. Ever since we bought one of those "safety" manual can openers we haven't used our electric one.
Bread machine was last used about two years ago, and our juicer hasn't been used in at least three years. The cleanup on that is rather cantankerous.
 
yeah it is more 'what's your life like?'

I don't use an electric can opener, nor a countertop grill. I have extensively used a juicer in the past (think several decades ago) but the thing I DO use frequently is a bread machine, for gluten and gluten free bread (we have 2).

I just love the generalization though.
 
What do I win?

Interesting...  Unless a stored juicer attachment for a Mixmaster counts, I have none of these appliances.  I had a breadmaker once and used it exactly one time and stored it for a year before getting rid of it.  Some like it for making dough, etc. so I can see if you have the space that it would be handy.  My mother and grandmother never had an electric can opener while i was growing up, we did have one that mom got as a wedding gift but when it went bad, hand-held Swing-Aways were bought and that's what I'm still using today - I have my grandmother's.  I don't eat a lot of meat so a countertop grill wouldn't last long even if it were free.

 
 
Electric Can Openers - There Is a Sensible Reason People Buy

Ms. Sullivan seems not to realize that people with limitations such as arthritis, or weak hand muscles, exist in the real world.

Have you ever tried to use a hand-held can opener during an arthritis flare-up? An electric can opener is hardly a frill here!
 
Juicer - never owned one

Breadmaker - never owned one, usually make rolls which are done in the stand mixer

Countertop Grill - "George" has gone back into the closet

Electric can opener - used to have one, but now use Oxo Good Grips hand model. Easier to keep clean, and it opens all sizes, including #10
 
I have only the juicer. Two, in fact; one citrus (a gorgeous Philips) and one for vegetables and non-citrus fruits (a Waring). Both get used often enough to warrant having them. I do loves me some fresh orange juice and fresh carrot juice.

Grew up with an electric can opener, but have never been tempted to get one for myself.
 
The only of the above gadgets I have are the can opener(only because it seems to hold up better than the string of lousy hand models) and as for a juicer I have the juicer attachment for my MixMaster which I do use routinely for making fresh orange juice and lemon juice for lemonade and cooking
 
I have a can opener because my coordination problem makes using a manual opener just too difficult. I my own bread with food processor and oven. Never wanted a countertop grill nor a juuicer.
 
Jucier - Yes, two vintage hand types. One is a "reamer" the other a German made "press" type. Both are only really used for obtaining citrus juice for baking or cooking with the occasional lemon juice for tea (iced or hot), and lemonade.

Counter Top Grill - Yes, have a decent sized (want to say Hamilton Beach) electric grill we use when it's too hot to even think about lugging out the cast iron stove top version. Used near a window with fan on "exhaust".

Electric Can Opener - Had a vintage one purchased NIB from thrift shope but moved it on after reading about possible germs because unlike hand cranked models cannot be washed. Went back to my older metal "Ecko" can/bottle opener that can and is washed in soapy water after each use.

Breadmaker - We've done that in another thread. If one likes fresh home baked bread they can be a godsend during warmer/humid times of the year, and or one lacks time to do the thing from scratch. OTHO if bread and or baked goods aren't big in your household don't bother.
 
I'm fine with the Swing-A-Way handheld can opener. "Like the astronauts use."

Back when I went through 3 gallons of iced tea with lime a week, I used the rotary juicer so much I had to take it apart and regrease it. But eventually that much tea was keeping me awake and I gave it up for beer. Fresh orange or red grapefruit juice is fun but expensive and the quality varies more than processed.

When I was a kid, maybe 6, we had a compression juicer. One morning I woke up early and wanted tomato juice. I figured if it worked with oranges it would work with tomatoes. Not exactly.
 
Make it FIVE, counting "Eggers"...

I use my juicer fairly often--at least enough that I think it's a reasonable buy, even though I don't often like cleaning off all that pulp from regular/not-so-regular use...

A bread-maker is an appliance I would have liked to have had for part of my wedding set--in fact I think my sister has one, but then given that I've never once had ONE SLICE of bread from her's must mean she might have taken her's back or to this day might have never used (or given me any from????)

An Electric Can Opener? Seriously? I LOVE mine & if not for the few canned things around here I open, I know I would use it more than I make milkshakes w/ my blender! It's a Hamilton Beach Opening Station, so it has a package opener (which really DOESN'T open a lot of difficult-to-open packages like I thought it would) and a jar opener on top that I think I stuck in a drawer, while the can opener and a few of other appliances had to be moved for a holiday, and the jar opener just not put back on afterwards when our "regular set-up" returned... (And we have a hand operated one in case the electricity goes out, too...!)

Well, I have a counter-top GRIDDLE and I hope that is OK to have--I would be lost if I didn't have it to make pancakes on and fried eggs, too! I recently moved it to the kitchen (though it was mighty hard to find space for) and only had to tell my wife ONCE not to set anything (her keys) on...!

Seriously, I wonder why EGGERS are not on this list! You know: those things for making hard boiled eggs... I feel like starting a thread to discuss what a mess those were and how lousy my hard boiled eggs (and a friend of ours, which should have warned me before I went out & bought mine!) turned out...!!!!

-- Dave
 
Breville loves me.

I have both their citrus juicer and their basket juicer. The local Asian supermarket sells these huge carrots which make for excellent carrot juice. I absolutely love freshly squeezed orange juice, the pulpier the better. Actually, I just drink the juice first then eat all of the pulp later.

Breville is the only company I'm aware of that sells an all stainless steel juicer which is actually easy to clean, as opposed to some other juicers which are a nightmare to clean. I love how I can feed it a big thick carrot and it just eats it.

My parents had a Sunbeam juicer and I nearly burnt the motor out on it because the juicing basket blade was so damn dull.

I had a cheaper bread maker and I didn't mind using it, but when you consider that you can just get bread from the store for so much cheaper and with much less fuss, it really only came in handy for artisan breads.

When you think about it, a bread maker shares a lot in common with a washing machine. It's got an inner tub, an "Agitator" and even a heating element. (If you count Euro-Style machines.) I really enjoyed watching it mix and beat the dough through the window, but the rest is kind of boring.

My wife would maim me if I bought a Breville Bread machine, we'd probably use it only a few times a year and only for special breads.

I want to pick up a countertop grill, my old panini grill was a massive pain in the hiney to clean and eventually the stop which held the upper lid broke, so I got rid of it. I'd rather have one of these, then I can just put the plates into the dishwasher and forget about it when I'm done.

(Link below)

I'll admit, I love making panini's, but I think it would be nice to make other things like burgers, bacon, etc with it.

One thing we really haven't used a lot is our raqlette. We were kind of hoping to do a raqlette style fondue, but it involves a lot of work and we just don't have time to make that happen. So, we very rarely use it.

I bought a Hamilton Beach can opener, the special kind that undoes the lid of the can instead of cutting it, because my wife badly cut her finger once. It does the job but sometimes it can be frustrating to use.

One of the reasons why we both hate using manual can openers is because we're both left handed, so they are a pain to use and left handed ones are hard to find here. So, it's just easier to use an electric one. I can't imagine any modern household without one, it just saves so much time and effort.

 
I grew up with an electric can opener - my mom loved hers. It had a built-in knife sharpener on the back and she used it all the time. When I got all growed up I found that I love a wall mounted "Swing Away" can opener much better as it didn't take up counter space and the crank made it very easy to open cans quickly.

Way back when bread machines first hit the scene and the prices started to come down, I purchased an Oster bread machine. For the first few months, I probably make at least a loaf a week, and enjoyed experimenting with different recipies. As life got busier, I found myself buying bread at the bakery/store and the Oster just collected dust. I finally sold it at a yard sale for a few dollars. Hope it went to a good home!

I felt the need for a juicer because if I wanted lemon, lime or orange juice I just used a reamer. But when I heard Ina Garten (The Barefoot Contessa) talk about how she couldn't live without her Braun juicer, I felt compelled to get one (the power of a celebrity endorsement!). Luckilly for me, I saw one at a thrift shop for $4 and it works beautifully. I must admit I don't use it much and could have lived without it, but it's in the cabinet.

The electric grill is something I never purchsed. I've have always had a "grill pan" which I use on the stove from time to time and it works well. They will have to pry my electric skillet out of my cold, dead hands, however! That is one appliance I couldn't live without.
 
Can Openers

Spiraltor, I agree with you completely on someone with arthritis or weak hands needing an electric can opener. If it's necessary, it's necessary.

Laundress, I had 2 Ekco can openers (one regular size and a smaller one) which I literally wore out. I can't even tell you how many years I had them. When the larger one literally fell apart, I went to Wal Mart to look for another Ekco replacement. None were to be found, so I settled on something that looked similar to it. Big mistake. I can't remember the exact length of time, but I believe it lasted a total of 6 WEEKS!

I started searching high and low for an Ekco at numerous stores, but came up bupkus on that. I finally settled on a Farberware brand which I bought at Big Lots. It does what it needs to do, but on occasion, I have to clean it up (run an old toothbrush along the gear and cutter) in order to get it to perform properly.
 
juicer

Come to think of it , I do have one: a manual citrus juicer I bought at a thrift shop solely to extract juice when making marmalade.

So I use it once/twice per year, does that mean I should get rid of it? LOL.
 
We like our Foreman grill for certain things, like grilling burgers and smoked sausage. The non-stick grills pop off and go into the dishwasher, which makes cleanup easy. It is definitely faster cooking with heat on both the top and bottom, and the slanted cooking surface does help grease drain away.

The only thing it doesn't do as well with is cuts of meat that aren't perfectly flat on both sides, like chicken breasts. We've never tried steaks on it; those go on the outdoor grill or under the broiler.

For awhile I had a large Cuisinart counter-top grill where the grill surface could be flipped over and used as a flat-surface griddle. That didn't work well at all and was given to Goodwill. It took forever to heat up, and the heating element made cooking uneven. I used the griddle a couple of times for pancakes, and you could see the lines of the heating elements as the browned section on the pancake surface.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top