This might explain some of the differences in our opinions about Maytag DW's:
1) SILVERWARE BASKET-- Mine splits into two skinny halves, which can be placed along the sides. This is the first thing I did when I got my machine. It would drive me crazy to have it front & center, restricting the loading of large items. In fact, I can usually get along using only one of the skinny halves, which opens up even more room in the bottom rack. The split-basket was available only on a few models.
2) QUIETNESS-- My machine has their most recent sound-dampening system, which is called QuietWash 400 (or something like that). It's my understanding that my machine isn't as quiet as a BoschMore, but compared to my Frigidaire, it's noticeably quieter--and that machine wasn't as loud as the mid-90's TOL KitchenAid I had.
3) TIERED UPPER RACK-- This was my biggest concern in getting a Maytag. After a few days of getting acquainted with how to load it, I'm sold. My top rack is adjustable up and down by several inches, which increases loading flexibility in both the top and bottom racks.
4) Fit & Finish-- I'm not seeing any problems with my machine. The door is certainly more solid than was the one on my previous DW. However, I don't have an early 80's Maytag to compare it with.
Reasons #1-3 are why I chose Maytag's TOL machine with a stainless interior, rather than one of the other models. Having said all this, many Kenmores, Bosches and BoschMores score higher in Consumer Reports' ratings, and there must be a reason for that. I know part of the reason is that Maytag DWers aren't as energy/water efficient as the above-mentioned machines. Truth be told, if there was a Sears store near me, I'd probably have purchased a BoschMore. My local choices were Frigidaire (been there), Whirlpool (been there), KitchenAid (been there) and GE (don't care for the dealer). I'd never owned a Maytag before and decided to try one. So far, I'm happy with my choice!