Spider Corrosion, And Foul Odors, In Front Load Washers

Automatic Washer - The world's coolest Washing Machines, Dryers and Dishwashers

Help Support AutomaticWasher.org:

Grounding Of SS Tubs And Spiders Etc

All these parts are deliberately grounded on most FL or TL washers, so grounding does not seem help, on machines with plastic outer tubs there is a ground wire running to the bearing hub, this id done for safety in case the heater or other electrical part fails and comes into contact with the basket which could present a hazzard to the appliances user.

 

John L.
 
Is it not possible that there are many factors

Involved in corrosion? And most of those factors are mitigated through cleaning? Some corroding factors are no doubt enhanced by the manner in which a machine is used.

I've mentioned here before that I spent a long time cleaning and repairing machines in Germany. Spider corrosion was minimal, even on the lowest-end Italian machines.

And they do, indeed, use chlorine bleach in Italy.

They also let the machines dry out (open doors) let the machines heat the water to temperatures which minimize microbial slime build up (and guess what that slime does) and use detergents which actually, you know, clean.

American makers (and those programming otherwise European machines) for quite a while refused to learn from the 50+ years experience of the rest of the world. At the same time as they were not putting drain holes in the boots, lowering water levels to non-functional levels and using poor programming and poor quality materials there were two other factors at hand:

1) No heating elements - the absurdly weak 110V/15Amp (110, 115, 117, 120, 121, 125, 127VAC, for the a-retentive) power available makes more than lukewarm washing impossible.

2) Until very recently, the phosphate free detergents on offer in the US were beyond useless.

 

So, yeah, galvanic corrosion is a thing. So is corrosion from the microbial slime. Heck, I wouldn't be surprised to find evidence that cavitation plays a role.

It's not the chlorine bleach, primarily, it's the build up of microbes and filth coupled with arrogant manufacturers who couldn't be bothered to research because, after all, what could the rest of the world know?
 
I highly doubt that the suggested cleaning procedure for our 2008 Affinity FL has much, if any impact on the spider.  It's just a standard wash cycle with bleach, which I run perhaps twice a year on average.

 

Our Duet OTOH, employed a medium speed spin during its "Clean Washer" cycle that threw the bleach solution into every possible nook and cranny.  Since the Affinity doesn't even possess a dedicated cycle for cleaning,  I'm amazed that we've gotten over nine years of service from it without a catastrophe.

 
 
My duet is from 2005 before clean washer cycles were on the washers. However, I learned after 5 or 6 years of owning it that I can press a sequence of buttons to activate a clean washer cycle where it fills with a lot of water and spins rapidly with throwing water EVERYWHERE! I think I have to press select drain/spin. select warm/cold, cycle signal to low, and extra rinse 3 times or something like that. I haven't used it in a while. I got my manual out and it's indeed in the very back what the sequence is. I never even noticed it in the manual when I first read it.

I do wish our washers connected to 220V like the dryers or ranges. But even still, if I choose heavy duty/more soil or whitest whites more soil, and especially sanitary, my duet gets plenty hot, like dishwasher hot.
 
@ combo52;

Galvanic corrosion *IS* with absolutely no doubt the mechanism of destruction the fact that the two dissimilar metals have an electrolyte between them, current WILL FLOW, the current is generated as the weaker metal dissolved (zinc in the copper-zinc equation).

You are saying it's 'operator error' which is nonsense because it only can happen do to the systemic DESIGN FLAW.

Inventing a machine that IS A BATTERY at least (at all times while being used), does not let the designers of said machine off-the-hook just because people that happen to remove all the electrolyte out of the battery between uses manage to get longer life out of their battery. It's absolute fact.

A couple very simple solutions would have prevented this world-wide sham; paint the spider for $1 per machine would have done the trick.

You can't insulated the spider from the tub because they are bolted together, you'd have to use non-conductive bolts, that will not be possible. An insulating washer would possibly help because it will increase the thickness of the electrolytic film required to bridge the gap, but it just takes 'not the perfect soap' to build up just a 0.001" thickness per use and it can build up a centimeter in half a year.

The spider is grounded through the bearing, the tub is grounded through the bolts holding the spider to the tub. 'grounding' is related to the problem; the tub and spider are electrically connected.

I just realized a caveat; you COULD insulate the tub from the spider by using a non-conductive WASHER between the bolts/screw heads and the tub, while ALSO using an insulator between the tub and the spider.

The problem with that; is you just made a capacitor; a crappy one so hopefully wouldn't be able to build voltage. You also didn't eliminate the battery action if enough paste builds up.

I'm working on re-building a spider on one of these machines. The epoxy was not strong enough and the drum started to wobble. I will share my solution with photos as I resolve this issue.

If i retain any of the original aluminum spider I will paint it to eliminate conduction through the electrolyte. If I don't, I will be using steel for the new spider spokes and that should not have a different enough chemical make-up from stainless to generate a voltage.

My purpose in my initial post was to counteract any of the posting out there 'in the wild' of the internet trying to claim that the spider damage was other than galvanic corrosion; by measuring the voltage created across the spider to tub interface is absolute proof that the inner tub of *ANY AND ALL* known front loading washing machines *are a galvanic cell*. I'm not aware of any that paint the spider or use steel for the spider. Anybody aware of any examples that have an actual method to prevent galvanic corrosion, please do share.

The damage is absolutely and almost exclusively caused by galvanic corrosion. Chemical corrosion an every other example are negligible in comparison. If you were to etch aluminum with an acid or a base, it will build up a protective layer of the reactant, that will stop the reaction. Aluminum oxide is so tough, you can't weld through it, puh lease, bleach disolve? yeah right!

I showed the multimeter that demonstrates with ZERO doubt that galvanic corrosion absolutely happens, If I am wrong show me a chemical corrosion experiment demonstrating a real-world mixture dissolved into the ratio you will find in a FL machine and I will admit that *some small amount* of chemical corrosion may also cause some small amount of damage (maybe 10% of the damage).

The vast majority of damage of all these spiders is absolutely galvanic. If you use detergent that dissolves easily enough to drain and not leave residue it will only cause damage while the machine is running, but it will STILL always dissolve while the machine has soapy water; the electrolyte can be liquid not a paste.

-awr
 
Hi AWR, how come the spiders only corrode and break on machines that are used with cold water, too little detergent, and no chlorine bleach ?, explain that. If it was a design flaw all FL washers would corrode and fail and yet when FD redesigned their FL washers a decade ago and used a much heaver spider we have never seen one fail since, we have also never seen a SQ spider fail in commercial use.

 

We have far more real life experience with FL washers in real homes than you do, we have literately thousands of customers with FL washers and have seen nearly 1000 spiders fail and when you see the gunky machine it is never a surprise that it corroded and broke.

 

The other interesting thing is when these same home machines are used in commercial settings often washing up to 20 loads a day the spiders never corrode and break.

 

John L.
 
Easy enough to explain; I've worked on a few of these machines that almost exclusively use WARM water wash, occasional bleach use. 100% of the FL i've opened up have galvanic corrosion. (laws of physics dictate this should be expected)

It does TAKE YEARS (on the order of ten) to reach a point of evident failure from the operator's standpoint. It also makes sense that cold-water wash speeds up the destruction as the detergent will not dissolve as well into cold water no matter what the mfg brags. By adding thickness to the spider just makes it last longer; if it takes 10 years to fail with 0.15 thickness making it 0.20 thick might last 20-25 years and effectively eliminate the failure mode since something else will break first it's still a BAND-AID. a FIX eliminates the problem (e.g. paint the spider so no conduction can take place).

It makes perfect sense that the commercial machines don't have the failure mode; the continuous use prevents the dry off cycle that allows for the film to build up, they also may have a programmed in clean cycle or extra rinse, or the typical use pattern (hot water, more bleach etc) that remove the source of the electrolytic film/paste build-up. If they are regularly cleaned the galvanic corrosion can be the secondary corrosion and just normal chemical corrosion can be the primary wear, the thickness of the metal would allow it to last 40 years with just chemical corrosion (base etching the aluminum).

It's the pause between uses (home machines likely used 2-4x per week, perhaps less), that allows the film to dry between uses and turn into the paste that stays between washes and will build up and stay there 24-7 and not only be a galvanic cell while washing. If that film is greatly reduced by hot water, or extra rinse or continuous use, there won't be enough surface area in contact with both metals to create an effective battery cell. The paste builds up, sort of dries out but gets wetted each use, the wet paste sticks to new material each wash and it builds up a little more each time.

Facts are still facts; the corrosion we see on these spiders is demonstrably from galvanic corrosion. The MFG brags that we can use them to wash with cold water, but designed them so that if we do, they self-destruct that is the very definition of a design failure. They designed it to fail.

(they didn't do on purpose it was an oversight).

They don't design them differently for use in commercial machines afaik, so again, design FLAW; they know from 100 years of people using machines, that normal people want to use cold water both to keep clothes looking better and to spend less $ on heating water, they brag about it, specifically the brag is that FL machines can clean better with cold water, they also have a very specific guide of how much detergent to use each use so your too little soap comment doesn't hold water. The machine doesn't clear out the soap each use when used occasionally that is a design flaw (for a residential machine). The MFG will say to use only certain kinds of soap (as a band-aid to the design flaw, it's ludicrous). If TIDE could be proven to be the primary cause of the spider destruction that would be a very big lawsuit.

To be clear MY discussion pertains exclusively to the residential use of a FL washing machine. As far as i can tell every single one has the same design flaw; an uncoated aluminum spider electrically attached to a steel drum and collects a growing film of soap residue that is an electrolyte. That is is *possible* to treat the machine 'just right' and only have a self-destructive machine every time it's operating vs 24-7 doesn't negate the fact that every MFG overlooked the galvanic problem and to this day is pretending it doesn't exist so they won't have legal liability that goes back 40-50 years when they first made the decision to not coat the spiders when some smart engineer noticed that it's a galvanic cell and sent a memo that is locked deep deep in a safe buried in a mountain that said they should coat the spiders or they could be having a problem as the spider consumes itself.

It is implausible that 'they didn't know' mechanical engineers KNOW. They knew, they know now, they will know in a decade that it was a bad decision to put dissimilar metals into an electrolyte and to save money they chose to not paint the spiders. It took 15-20 years to really find out the gravity of their mistake and since 100s of MILLION$ are on the line they must lie and cover-up the truth. If people died from it and not just forced to replace a $1000 machine twice as often, the recall and lawsuits would be monumental. One could argue planned obsolesce and they did it on-purpose so that people would have to replace the machine more often, they could even argue it's a conspiracy among all the brands since they all have the problem, and people will very likely NOT by the SAME brand (ironically switching from kenmore to whirlpool etc), and not realizing that ALL BRANDS have the same systemic failure problem.

it's also a FACT that maintained in 'just the right way' it will be possible to avoid the galvanic destruction when used in a residential setting. This will require non-normal use of a machine, it will require maintenance outside the normal use 'plug and play' that 99% will follow, only the 1% will go through the effort required to prevent the problem.

So summary: your statement "only machines which use cold water and too little detergent" is not accurate at all. You personally are in a situation of "can't see the forest for the trees" because you see too many machines and the apparently percentage is too many commercial machines.

100% of the residential machines that i've worked on have this problem. I'm working out a preventative maintenance solution to add years to these machines' lives by taking out the drum, sand-blast the gunk off the spider and paint them. The galvanic corrosion will stop in its tracks and some other part can be the 'end of life' failure mode.

Google galvanic corrosion hall of shame, or similar, you will find 1000s of pictures of this problem. I'm not saying it's not possible to avoid the problem, i'm saying that laws of physics dictate that ANY two dissimilar metals that are in an electrolyte and have an electrical connection will generate electricity and the anode of the two will dissolve that's simply how it works, 100% of the time. You can slow the rate the anode dissolves by reducing any of the factors; how much surface area is touching both the electrolyte and the two metals, use different metals, etc, but as long as they are different, touching, and bathed in electrolyte it's the very definition of a galvanic cell and will dissolve.

-awr
 
Before this is all considered "fact," there needs to be more chemical and mechanical/material study. And typing it all in caps doesn't make it more so.
These are claims from your observation, and even John's observation.
The tests and observations are of course interesting and appreciated.
Some of those observations coincide, and some seem not to.
It seems like this issue can have a lot of facets. From part design, metal composition, assembly procedure, customer use, additives used, home conditions, WATER conditions etc etc.

(example: I have very alkaline water, softened, 8 - 8.5ph, whereas my parents have hard, Chicago water at 7.0ph. Our appliances wash very differently with different detergents.)

I'd like to hear from some appliance engineers hiding in the weeds on this issue.
If it is in fact some kind of rampant galvanic issue, I'm sure the appliance engineers work on this and with it.

**Please engineers, come forth. Help us understand.
You do not have to reveal what house you work for. **

Also, for this to be truly scientific, we need lots of peer reviewed and repeated experimentation and observation.

This crisis also reminds me of my pharmacist dad, who insists that all of society is sick and on drugs. Well, yeah from his perspective. All he sees is the sick people....cuz they need his drugs! He's not seeing the vast swaths of healthy people.
This here, if it was that much of a corrosion pandemic, it would be all over the news and we'd be covered in stories of exploding front loaders.
Which we're not.
Not to say it NOT a problem. But it seems like a minor one in the market.
As always, "more study" is needed.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fact

A fact is a statement that is true or can be proven with evidence. The usual test for a statement of fact is verifiability — that is, whether it can be demonstrated to correspond to experience. Standard reference works are often used to check facts. Scientific facts are verified by repeatable careful observation or measurement (by experiments or other means).

Thank you AWR for your "thesis" and I would happily like to see these claims re-tested to see how the observations and electrical measurements match up.

Also, I'll offer this thread for further reading. The comments were interesting:
https://fixitnow.com/wp/2009/10/28/...ion-contagion-a-menagerie-of-metallic-misery/

^ there's a link in there about a WP Canadian court case where WP had to change the aluminum specs and design to reduce corrosion, which it seems they did around 2008.
 
But what about the bolts that go through the SS drum into the aluminum spider ?

 

You are correct Greg, just putting a plastic washer between the two different metals does little good, there are ways to use special fasteners to do this but it affects the strength of the assembly.

 

Painting or coating of the aluminum would likley do very good as well, when washers had pot-metal aluminum water pumps manufactures tried different epoxy coatings etc and they did as much harm as good, because moisture would get under the coating and corrode even more quickly.

 

Greg I would be willing to bet when you do an autopsy on your 20+ YO Asko some day that the spider will look close to new.

 

John L.
 
Hi Guys

It is corrosion pure and simple, they corrode in this area because this is where the bio-film [ crud from poor washing habits ] accumulates and keeps the area moist.

The notion of impurities in the aluminum is ridiculous, all three arms are corroded in the same area, if it were impurities it would have to be random.

John L.
 
Are these spiders anodized? It seems that might help, as anodizing is a form of corrosion and it might not do any more in use. Again, I wonder if Alcoa (Arconic?) research has done anything to solve this issue.
 
"impurities in the aluminium is ridiculous"

If it is made of a mixture of various metals, then there could be different stress tolerances and flaws in the mixture (eg. air bubbles).

I was thinking that since all three arms are cracked at the same point, it must be stresses caused by the twisting force of the drum shaft.
 
Corroded Spiders

You have to remember that due to poor washing and usage habits this area of the spider that corrodes and breaks is coated in over a 1/2" of toxic gunk that stays wet all the time, even anodizing or epoxy coatings over aluminum will fail under these conditions.

When manufactures design and build these washers they never imagined that people could misuse them is badly and in extensive factory and commercial testing these same machines NEVER fail.

John L.
 
Maybe some enterprising soul should send a sample of the drum spider for metallurgical analysis. Then we could find out exactly what it is made of. But it might vary batch to batch, manufacturer to manufacturer.
 
Vary batch to batch

Oh, I don't know - with parts coming from deepest darkest China, anything is possible.

You only need to look at all the carry on with dodgy lithium batteries, faulty chargers and so on to realise not everything is manufactured 'just so'.
 
Not everything from China is bad.

Production in China is actually extremely accurate (good factories, not the xing ling ones) and they make everything according to specs.

But when they're given poor specs to save money (and 1 cent per unit makes a huge difference on the final price) plus the consumers desperate for the cheapest bargain at Amazon or Walmart, the result is the poor crap we see nowadays.

So everything can be reduced to only two words: PRODUCTION COST.

There are two ways to deal with it nowadays:

1) Make good products and have people saying "OMG, this washer is much more expensive than the one i saw on the previous link, this manufacturer is trying to steal my money, I'll buy the cheapest one because I'm smart, even knowing that the cheapest one is a crap with 90 day warranty and the expensive one comes with a 3-year warranty and costs 10% more.

2) Follow the beaten path and make crap so the price will be similar to the competitor. Give the "Chinese" factory specific orders to cut every cent on production, go as cheap as possible, to become competitive.
 
The spiders problem doesn't have one cause. It's a series of things that together creates a time bomb.

1) Ridiculously low water levels (D.O.E.)
2) Poor quality materials (not exactly poor, but there is a ways to make it better, but it costs more)
3) Impossibility to make it cost more because consumers want as cheap as possible.
4) Millenials that think that just tossine 1 tide pod is enough. Because it has everything, right? it should perform amazingly well and we don't need to spend money on other additives.
5) Americans want everything fast, extremely fast, the washer must wash, dry, fold and put the clothes back in the closet in 3 minutes.
6) The bigger the better, so let's toss all the laundry, the cat, the dog, the husband, the kids, the mattress and the sofa all together in one load and select the quick cycle. If it doesn't come out clean or if it destroys the washer, let's blame the manufacturer because we're paying, so we can do whatever we want and the manufacturer will always be wrong.
7) Use only cold water. Hot water is so 1970's. we need to save the world and hug trees. Should be add some ice cubes and make a "wash on the rocks"? It doesn't matter if the final rinse drains like snot or if the clothes are dingy What matter is the washer using as little water as possible. and to mask the stench, we can add more fabric softener, more scent booster, spend more money buying odor or stain rescue pods, odor neutralizers, etc.
8) Let's keep the door closed after every use. Who cares if it will create the perfect environment for mold? We can sue the manufacturer if we had mold issues. This is 2018, the manufacturers should have created a way to prevent mold without changing our bad habits.
 
Someday I'll create a thread with the stupid questions I receive almost every day.

the top rank is:

1) Can I wash a king size duvet in a WonderWash washer?
2) Do I need to use detergent with your washers? How can you say you're a green company if we need to use detergent to wash clothes?
3) Is it really necessary to rinse the clothes after washing? But I use Tide Pods, doesn't it do everything at once?
4) I believe there is a mistake on the user manual, it says you can use hot water. Don't you know that using hot water will destroy our planet?{
5) I let the clothes running for one hour in your spin dryer but they're not completelly dry. they don't even get hot, i think the product is defective. And also, the clothes leave the machine horribly wrinkled.
 
Dissimilar metals

Ok, Ok, Ive followed this thread for enough time.

Dissimilar metals can be a serious issue without proper protection, and that includes mixing stainless and aluminum. I worked at an oil refinery for many years as a control room operator/plant operator and currently work at a hospital doing the same thing so I have lots of experience with piping, metals, codes, requirements etc... Two metals that should never be fastened together without proper protection is stainless steel and carbon steel. Stainless has most of its excess minerals removed making it mostly impervious to corrosion. However, because of this, it will pull these minerals from carbon steel, or other metals with a higher mineral content, like aluminum. This is measured as the current potential between metals, noble and anodic metals.

Demineralized water codes and engineering requirements completely prohibit the use of carbon steel on demineralized water piping as the demineralized water will pull the impurities and minerals right out of the carbon steel, thus causing galvanic corrosion.

"just putting a plastic washer between the two different metals does little good"

The truth is this actually does great good. Some of our instrumentation such as flow meters have stainless bodies and are on carbon steel lines. Between the flanges are a gasket that is not made of metal, plastic. This works very well and retards the corrosion to a very predictable slow rate.

Water will act as an electrolyte for this corrosion to occur. And because residential water from the utility or well is very high in conductivity, this will only speed up the galvanic corrosion and cause the water to be a much better electrolyte.

 

How much of the aluminum spider actually touches the stainless drum, surface area, is different from manufacturer to manufacturer. The surface area for sure has an effect on how fast and where this type of corrosion occurs. Im not surprised the spiders fail where they do as I feel the cracking right next to the drive shaft is happening at a high stress area, and there is no question these aluminum spiders look corroded when they come out of a broken machine.

 

I personally believe this spider issue isnt one golden nugget problem but rather a calamity of issues. I believe the dissimilar metals and galvanic corrosion has a serious effect on the spiders life time, the stainless pulling whatever it can out of the aluminum and weakening it at a high stress point (which you can tell its the highest stress point since the metal is beefier there). Couple that with customers not leaving their doors open to allow the machine to air dry, using too little bleach to prevent the buildup of organic material which can very well contribute to the demise since those bacterial processes can create acidic environments.

 

Theres a multitude of errors here, theres not one smoking gun.
 
So, corrosion up to the point where stresses take over.

I just wish they'd use materials a tad more robust. It'd save everyone a lot of grief.
 
non-aluminium spider

I have the drum and backplate assembly from an old Asko in my shed. It is from a model 12004, whenever that was - pre-2000 for sure. (I still have 2 complete machines of the same model too, needing minor repairs, but still with their original bearings and spider in good condition.)

It has a stainless steel spider - flat pressed stainless steel, welded to the centre shaft. It still has the backplate attached so it is a bit difficult to see, but it is clear enough. No al.

I wonder what newer Askos do?
 
It has to be a multitude of issues that brings machines to this point. I dont believe its one solid thing that causes the chain of events.

 

I had a front load GE in my old townhouse that was brand new. I had it five years and always took care of it as the instructions said so. Never grew mold or anything. It may be a symptom of North Americans not understanding that FL machines arent care free like TL.

 

Speaking of that, does this issue occur in Europe? Or is it a North American issue? What brands are more prone to failure?
 

Similar threads

maytagneptune
Costco Kirkland Signature Laundry Detergent corrosion inhibitors?
Replies
3
Views
468
maytagneptune
maytagneptune
S
Has there been any solution to spider-arm corrosion?
2
Replies
59
Views
1K
combo52
combo52
O
LG WASHER SPIDER CORROSION
Replies
28
Views
1K
ls
L
M
Speed Queen Front Load AFN50 Washer Review - Long Post
Replies
15
Views
585
jetcone
jetcone
D
E.Coli on laundry (not for the highly-squeamish!)
2
Replies
55
Views
748
tolivac
T

Latest posts

Back
Top